Name
|
Details
|
| 8163) | |
| Iqbal |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Friday, July 2, 2010 09:08 PM PST Reply: 
Dear all,
I would like to purchase 1 Kanal plot to make house for my own living in a gated community after 3 years near to Thokar Niaz Beg on Canal, Multan or Raiwind road.
For this purpose I visited 3 socities last week namely Lake City, Bahria Town sector C, Sukh Chayan. All seems to me good as per their development standard and facilities.
I need advice from you that which one I should select out of three for living after 3 yrs where all facilities like school, hospital, Mosque, shopping malls, Gym. etc will be available by that time. If you select any society, please also select the best block and street and market price to there in order to decide.
Thanks for your help and sincere advice.
Regards
Thanks for your expert opinion.
Regards
Decision replied on Friday, July 2, 2010 10:24 PM PST
you know I can understand people on this forum asking for investment advice and pros and cons of real estate investment but what I can not understand is that why people ask complete strangers where to make a house the place where one is to live and spend there life and raise there kids. A person should at least know this much for him self. Iqbal just chose a place where you feel you would be comfortable and can enjoy life with out worries of distance, socially cut of from population and most of all security. |
visitor99 replied on Saturday, July 3, 2010 12:26 AM PST
i think its better to get information before investment.last descion is always your hand.try lakecity villas,but try to get in dreams streat villas,very beautifull location. |
shahid replied on Saturday, July 3, 2010 08:59 AM PST
all blocks of BT under cnstuction. After three years go for janiper or overseas enclave B batch. It is too cheap now a days and is on negative side. But after three years it will be same as other blocks of BT. Every facility available in BT sector C including cinema and medical college. |
Daniyal replied on Saturday, July 3, 2010 12:13 PM PST
Go for Vaencia/NFC Society.
Price 1k 35-45,
10M 25-30.
Secure and fully developed |
|
| 8162) | |
| Khalid |
| | City & Country: Overseas Pakistani | |
 Sunday, June 20, 2010 09:40 PM PST Reply: 
Sector D-12 and Your Sincere advise
Hello Islamabad 
I made a request few days back to get a sincere advise from the friends of Islamabad but unfortunately did not get proper response and neither a creditable expertise of Islamabad commented on my request.
Kindly tell me is it worth to invest in sector D-12 and when do you think this sector will be in position to live 
Have the construction of houses started and how many ?
Is the Margala Avenue has started if not is it in pipe line yet or contract awarded. ?
Where do you see the future on sector D-12
Please write whole heartedly as it is matter of my hard earn money
Oversease Help line replied on Sunday, June 20, 2010 10:15 PM PST
Khalid! whole hearted and sincere advice---- 80% sure D-12 is not faverable investment for 5 years. Khalid do not purchase land for short or mediam term basis investment .Keep your money with you in dollers if you are not in country.Think for investment after returning back to pakistan.
Majeed_ajk@hotmail.com |
Aamir replied on Sunday, June 20, 2010 10:40 PM PST
D-12 may not be a feasible option long and/or short term investment it would require some time to mature. However, construction of own house in D-12 is another story. G-13 and E-11 are hot selling sectors these days. I do own plot in E-11. After 3 days of my purchase I was offered Rs 2.5 Lacs profit but I am not selling it off for the time being.
Because of the prevalent situation in Pakistan it requires a careful Marketing research to make any investment decision especially in real estate. |
Khayyam Shahzad replied on Monday, June 21, 2010 01:36 AM PST
Khalid bhai,
Without knowing your investment goals, it is hard to comment on it. I can tell you that there are four houses being constructed now including mine. It is of course just the beginning and more houses will be built soon when the grid station is completed by the end of this month.
As for livable place to live. Different people have different ideas about when a place is livable. Some won't live in a place until 75% homes are completed. Other may be ok with 15-20% homes built. Most new areas I have seen people live when there are about 15-20% homes completed.
No one can question the location and long term prospective of any proper CDA sector. Make no mistake about it D-12 IS a proper CDA sector.
Also many experts agree that Real estate investment should be a along term investment. Only time will tell what D-12 will look like in 2, 5 and 10 years from now. Knowing how many people have waited several decades to build their homes in this area, especially retired government officials, I have complete faith that this will be a very livable place in a short 2 years from now or less. Of course ALLAH know the best; this is just my educated guess.
Lastly, yes the world economy including Pakistan is down. They say 'buy low and sell high'. Based on that statement alone it is good time to invest in the real estate market in general. I am not only talking specifically about Pakistan but generally speaking. You have to do your own due diligence to make sure you make the best investment. You must also consider law and order situation in Pakistan.
Here is my understanding of the current rates of some of the proper Islamabad CDA sectors for one kanal plot:
F10/F11 -> 2 - 2.5 caror
F8 -> 2.5 - 3 + caror
D-12 -> 1.2 - 1.5 caror
E-7/E-8 too high to even compare!
NOTE, these are my rough idea of the price ranges and may be not completely accurate. Therefore Islamabad experts please correct me if I wrong.
My point is due to D-12 superior geographic location and being a proper CDA sector it may be equally pricey if not more expensive than other comparable CDA sectors in a few years from now. Only time will tell for sure. I feel good about my investment and don't regret it even in the recent downturn. Do note that I bought my plot at a high time when the $/Ruppee exchange rate was 60. Today it is at 85. Despite that I still think it is a good investment for me from long term perspective. The only regret I have is I wish I would have bought now vs two yeas ago as it would have cost me a lost less. |
abd replied on Monday, June 21, 2010 01:39 AM PST
Dear Khalid,
I believe D-12 is last greatly valued sector of Islamabad, you will not find an other opportunity to have your dream house in Islamabad if you missed out D-12. May be there will be few sectors in G and I series but not in D,E or F. This sector will have value as Harley street Rawalpindi was having being close to GHQ in early days of Pakistan.
The development of D-12 was awarded on political base therefore suffered a lot but it is all most completed now and few houses are already started and many more are ready to start in few week time.
I own a plot in D-12 which I purchased in 2002 and it has gained 6 time in price, this can happen in CDA sector of Islamabad only.
Every one can not define Islamabad but trust me who visit once don't wanted to return, for you it is my sincere advise if you can afford buy and start enjoying. Who knows what you are Carrying in pocket but having a house in Islamabad will give you satisfaction pride respect and dignity.
Do not forget Islamabad is a city of tasteful people and D-12 has fantastic location and scenic view and close to Margala hills, GHQ,few minutes from Faisil masjid, peer sahawa and Secretariats.
In simple it is worth to buy and live But off course it is expensive |
Mian Nadeem replied on Monday, June 21, 2010 01:01 PM PST
I agree with abd;
Mr Aamir in G-13 more than 600 houses are constructed and Price is lower than D-12 why? When only 100 houses in D-12 will constructed price will more then E-11. |
MACH replied on Monday, June 21, 2010 03:23 PM PST
Mr. Khayam shahzad
i have also a plot 35x70 in D-12. I also want to start the construction. please guide for design,layout plan,architecture name , contractor name, & I aslo want to see your under construction house in D-12, please give your plot # & sub sector #,
my e-mail is (mach_5932@yahoo.com) |
Khayyam Shahzad replied on Monday, June 21, 2010 03:45 PM PST
Dea MACH,
I will send you my details, house design/architecture and contractor details a little later today on your email directly. |
MAS replied on Monday, June 21, 2010 07:17 PM PST
Dear Khayyam Shahzad could you please forward the same info to my email address also as I am in the same boat.
Finding a good architect and contractor can make the difference of night and day as far as quality of construction goes. Other readers from Islamabad are also requested to share info if they had good construction experience before and can recommend someone. Some times I wonder who are the architects of the beautiful houses constructed in E-11 lately.
My e-mail address is beautifulislamabad@hotmail.com |
Khayyam Shahzad replied on Monday, June 21, 2010 07:32 PM PST
Will do MAS bhai within a few hours Insha-Allah. |
|
|
 Friday, June 18, 2010 04:36 PM PST Reply: 
Re post number 48137
Dear Dubai Investor,
I m fully agreed with Qaiser, please don’t put your hard earned money in Dubai. The following are the key disadvantages in real estate sector of UAE.
1. Govt’s inconsistence policies ( initially announced a 99 year visa for property owner and later revoked without any reason/justification)
2. 100% confirmed no rental or capital appreciation at least for near 5-8 years time. Demand has been on declining trend with substantial supply pumped in over the coming years.
3. No banks are willing to support the buyers and the actual buying power of the society is very limited hence in case you opt to sell your investment it’s nearly impossible in near future. Most of the buying power is artificially supported by consumer lending which has been dented extensively specially in Dubai.
4. Hidden costs like maintenance /service /community fees are very high
5. NO RIGHT what so ever you owned in this country. ( just for an example in case you have a street fight with cab driver there BOTH OF YOU WILL BE DEPORTED AND YOU LL NOT BE ABLE TO RETURN IN THE COUNTRY FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE)
6. The main concept of the real estate especially of UAE and particularly in Dubai was not logical, around the world , the Real estate investment considered on two ground i.e Social Security or long term investment but in Dubai the RE was treat as commodity trading and peoples had made hell of money but those days are OVER FOREVER now.
7. The financial health of big giants of UAE are in very bad shape , Dubai’s Nakheel. Emaar are actually bankrupt bcos they are not able to meet the financial obligations even refunding the money of customers are not possible , DP world is another disaster asking the lender to restructure their commitment /repayment . Stocks are rock bottom various shares are below par.
In short the I’ll give you an example if you have a property in Pakistan in any city with Market value of Say one Crore and you want to sell it for 80 Lacks , you will get the money in no time but in Dubai, investors are asking 50% below the original price BUT NO DEMEND.
DUBAI CHARM IS OVER , they are introducing so many indirect taxes on the expat population here to support their economy like living tax, paid parking across the UAE, tool tax, ID card ( with no use but AED: 300 for one year) etc.
My honest suggestion is to invest in the place where in case you can BURN TYPRES for agitation rather than just sit home cursing yourself for investing in place which doesn’t belong to you.
Regards
Kashif Riaz
DubaiInvestor replied on Friday, June 18, 2010 06:22 PM PST
Thank you Kashif bhai! You have provided very thoughtful and honest details. Other brothers knowledgeable in that market please feel free to provide your details as well
I live in US and one of the option I was thinking was to retire in Dubai due to lower cost of living, secure living and cheaper health care. However it seems like some of those perks are no longer valid. |
MAS replied on Friday, June 18, 2010 11:11 PM PST
Very educating post. |
usmani replied on Friday, June 18, 2010 11:18 PM PST
welldone,very very helpfull information.reality of your personality,keep it up. |
mohammad imran khan replied on Saturday, June 19, 2010 06:48 AM PST
i am writing this reply as i lost 40000 forty thousand US dollar in Ajman close to dubai, the developer got 3 years jail. Now the local partner got away as he is the son of ruler of Ajman. Invest in your hometown, punjab , sindh , balochistan , pakhtan khawa NWFP.I live in USA, and wast telling my son today you will not agree with me, but your country is pakistan, though he was born 25 years ago in new york. |
Steelfish replied on Sunday, June 20, 2010 10:58 AM PST
Salam Alikum, I have lived in this country for the last 20+ yrs, yes gained a lot from here, good job and supported family in Pakistan....but now unfortunetly, things and life is getting tougher and harder, lot of layoffs from jobs, no social security, one chq is bounced and u land up in jail etc, indirect costs are sky rocketing and property investments are almost null! Yes in Pakistan, sometimes property transactions are not clear but its our own country..u can be down but not out! unlike this artifical countries like here..
regards, |
|
|
 Tuesday, June 8, 2010 06:15 PM PST Reply: 
Our Budget & Economic Situation
What do you think the current economic situation, currency devaluation, inflation impact of taxes & energy crises will produce? - apart from deprived real-estate investment position, closing of small scale industries & businesses, it gives birth to social unrest.
The global financial crises has have raised many eye-brows of busy businessmen who once thought that the given geo-political situation will not effect their lives. Since then, not only individuals but institutions & Govts. have diverted their funds to safer investments, like gold, for rainy days. Some analysts say that the economic crises was a self-created havoc by the big bankers to suck more money from the Govts. in the name of bail-outs because after so much hue & cry end-of-the-day these banks are still there enjoying their authoritative positions. Whatever the case may be, but it has changed the way people think & their life style. So much global commercial inter-dependence demands a peaceful environment. (Just to remind you that the 2nd world war was the outcome of the great recession of 1930s). The inherent phenomenon of ‘urge to dominate’ stimulates opponents’ reactions. The present situation triggers for safer measures to be taken in the economic decision making & self-reliance.
However, present economic situation in Pakistan is becoming adversely surprising. Demand is ever increasing as the country of over 180 million people require basic necessities whereas the productivity & growth rate has fallen leading to beg for the necessities at the state level. In simple words nation is forced to fulfill its basic needs from ever-soaring internal & external loans. I can balloon-up this issue and can link this with the present ethico-geo-politico-socio-economic problems of our homeland and can start condemning govt. leading to some specific personalities which mostly people are doing these days over the net and the media. Some people feel by this way they can get self-satisfaction; it is proving to be wastage of energies. May Allah shower His Blessings upon responsible people & may Guide them the righteous path; however, unfortunately this was not evident in the recent federal budget. Health, education & employment was not even touched what to talk of big projects & supporting industries.
It would be an honour to hear from friends good suggestions as to how eradicate this situation & overcome our in-efficiencies. In this regard I have personally observed in my last year’s visit from Brussels to Paris by train… I met an Indian who was working with the European Union Commission for accelerating international trade & exchange. I wonder how their govt. is strengthening their already deep-rooted ties with developed nations even to the personal levels & gaining support as well as the business. Same is badly required by Pakistan at a faster pace from west, middle-east & the far-east & I wish that the Pakistani educated intelligentsia should come forward with a positive move & can provide suggestions if we have to bring a soft -revolution otherwise its hard-core version is dying to show its face.
|
|
 Monday, April 12, 2010 09:35 PM PST Reply: 
alpha beta replied on Monday, April 12, 2010 10:35 PM PST
and it looks like DHA decided to send me to the graveyard before my time...thanks to the ballot |
Scary replied on Monday, April 12, 2010 11:24 PM PST
:-) 2 MARLA! Is this a grave site or a commercial plot? I have never heard something so small :-) |
visitor replied on Tuesday, April 13, 2010 06:55 AM PST
dear alpha beta
its nice location you should open flower & cuffon shop:-) |
MJM Dammam replied on Tuesday, April 13, 2010 12:28 PM PST
Dear Scary - looks like you are new in this business or you have lack of knowledge. For your information in DHA Lahore all phases have 2 marla commercial plots, usualy they are called sector shops. For sector shops, 2 marla is enough space to have a small scale business activity |
|
| 8158) | |
| asim |
| | City & Country: isb | |
 Wednesday, April 7, 2010 10:59 PM PST Reply: 
price decline D-12 Prices have declined in D-12 sector after the announcement of possession and expert of isb realestate are saying that it can further come down for few months atleast to 1 crore rupee kanal 50x90 price and after the completion of electical work and proper electricity connections, prices will go back to possitive side or it will stay here for a while. best time to invest in d-12 would be after july and so on.
Investor replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 12:18 AM PST
I would like to buy a 50 * 90 plot or 60 * 90 plot in D-12. If anyone has anything available at such reasonable market rate please post your demand and plot/sector number. Thank you |
asim replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 04:17 AM PST
please contact at the following numbers.
just wait for few more months, price to touch its lower deapth 1 crore after budget.
you can get sastay plots of d-12 plz call for details:
+92 51 2104354, +92 51 55 66 57
+92 51 2104357
+92 300 5262561
+92-300-8527838, +92 345 8527838
+92-51-5879466 |
Investor replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 05:50 AM PST
Will do. Thank you |
allottee replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 11:41 AM PST
No decline, prices of D-12 increase day by day. After provsion of electricity & construction start 1 crore= 1-1/2 crore Inshallah.
Allottee |
Non-Expert of Isb Realest replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 02:12 PM PST
I just checked an alternate website that advertises dozens of plots along with their price demands. I noticed no clear decline. I have seen prices fluctuate a little in both directions on almost weekly basis for a long time.
I would still accept your statement if you would give me any logic. What would happen after budget. Why would budget make a difference. Are the experts of Islamabad real estate giving any reason or are they relying on astrology. CVT has already been imposed on all size plots. There is nothing new expected in the budget regarding plots.
Price did not touch 1 crore in the last couple years when we were unsure about its completion time. Why would it go down now when every one knows that electricity work will be completed in a few months and almost all service roads have been carpeted and access road from E-11 is fully carpeted. Any one visiting D-12 can see the grid station work going on very fast.
Of-course there can always be exceptions. There are several plots that are still under adverse possession or are on a street that has its entrance closed because of adverse possession or have some other problem. So if you are offered an exceptionally low price please go and physically check the location first and study the map well before deciding to buy.
Personally I have been offered an unbelievably high price for my plot just last week. Probably this was an exception too. May be there was some individual who wanted that location badly.
If a lot of people believe in your statement then certainly they will hold back on buying and the price will be affected. I however have difficulty in believing anything unless it is supported by reasoning. |
asim replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 04:59 PM PST
sir jee declining got no reasons in pakistan. prices coming down in d-12. check the market first |
Non-Expert replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 05:45 PM PST
You can help me check the market. Do you have any 1-Kanal plot on main double road in D-12/3 for 120 lakhs. Give the plot number here so all readers can benefit and may be call you to buy.
Can you give the price of any Margalla facing 1-Kanal plot in D-12/3 |
Buyer replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 06:12 PM PST
I also want Margala facing 1 kanal plot in D-12/3 or D-12/2. Anyone willing to sell please post the details. I have contacted many agents, but none responded back. |
asim replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 09:10 PM PST
if you had the money, you would not say that, you look alloty to me not an investor |
Buyer replied on Thursday, April 8, 2010 11:03 PM PST
Dear Asim bhai,
In my case you are right I already have a plot but it's 14 marla. I bought it at a peak time however I want to upgrade to 1 kanal or larger while keeping the other one for long term investment. Money is NOT an issues.
You have provided so many phone numbers (seven to be precise). All I am asking for is one real plot from a real seller in D-12/2 or 3 for the right price. Since you said the prices are down, please provide at least one for the record and for the transaction.
Thank you |
asim replied on Friday, April 9, 2010 12:51 AM PST
i provided you correct numbers, plots are available in 2 and 3. i think you didn't follow my point and you seem to be in arguing mood. the purpose of sharing the internal story for those only who are eagerly looking to purchase a plot in d-12 sector and the right time to come up in few months as prices to come further down. this info i not meant to hurt alloties and plot holders. so prices are coming down. |
asim replied on Friday, April 9, 2010 12:56 AM PST
@ Non-Expert
Brother you can easily get a plot in D-12/3 for 120 lakhs just check market and get info from sunday jang paper. |
Buyer replied on Friday, April 9, 2010 01:03 AM PST
Appreciate your help Asim bhai and notifying all of us a good opportunistic time to invest.
Even though I own one, I would love to invest in one larger one as I am amazed the prices are down right now despite the possession.
'Buy low sell high' they say :-). One cannot go wrong in real estate investment if able to weather the short-term fluctuations and ability to wait long term.
I will call the number tomorrow. |
Non-Expert replied on Friday, April 9, 2010 09:40 AM PST
So much discussion and not a single price quote of D-12/3 with plot number. Not a single reason why the next budget will effect real estate one way or the other.
I don't mean to be rude brother but a useful discussion requires more concrete information. |
Benchmark Realty replied on Friday, April 9, 2010 01:03 PM PST
Prices are not declining dear price are stable now a days. And price will grow up till june and after june. If electricity and ground work is going on then what's the reason of price declining. its understood that prices will grow up in the future. Any how its ur own point of view. |
|
| 8157) | |
| Imran |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Wednesday, January 20, 2010 12:10 PM PST Reply: 
Reference my post no. 45888 and other discussions posted for subject issue.
I am not spokesman of DHA, once again I am writing in personal capacity on this private forum.
Thousands of people have invested in DHA projects in three major cities. The reason behind is the credibility enjoys by DHA as market leader. I would like to highlight/clarify some important facts regarding DHA Islamabad projects in succeeding lines:
1. Mr. Shahzad and Mr. Usman are PM and Deputy PM of DHA Valley from Habib Rafique. I am from DHA and sitting in head office located in Ph. I
2. Habib Rafique and Bahria Town are development partners of DHA. Bahria Town is not financer. Finance is obviously coming from the installments paid by the members. So it is very logical to understand that investment is coming from DHA through its members.
3. Ph. I (Extn) & Ph. II (Extn) are in developing stages. In my view, remapping and other administrative issues will be resolved this year and than it will took 3 to 5 years depends on location, sector and country’s situation.
4. DHA has announced its Ph. III already. Ex-NPCHS (New Pindi Cooperative Housing Society) has merged in DHA as Phase. III. Transfers are also started. Plot holders are contacting the officials these days for updation of their record. Merger of AGOCHS-II is still in process.
Merger of any society is not an easy task. Just acquiring the land is not called merger. From by-laws of the company to plot size and dealing with the members a lot has to be done by new administration.
Ph. III is operational, please be updated.
5. File system has been adopted for the convenience of members, how else they can Sale/Purchase on initial stages. Once the development proceeds further the file/certificate system replaced with allotment letters. Allotment letter of DHA Ph. II (Extn) and DHA Valley (except Commercial Avenue) are already in practice, details of which can be confirmed.
6. DHA Valley is a mega project. Beside DHA Valley plot of 5 & 8 marlas, other projects like DHA Valley Overseas, Commercial Avenue and DHA Homes are located within DHA Valley. Valley includes all these projects. There are 20 main phases in Valley including 16 of DHA Valley, 3 of DHA Valley Overseas and 1 of DHA Homes. Commercial sector is located on the edge of each sector. DHA Home is located in the middle most of Valley and further divided into 2 sectors (A for 8 marlas and B for 5 marlas) and it is very much a part of DHA Valley.
7. First time DHA has allotted plots to the families of our shaheed jawans, who paid their life for our country. These 5 & 8 marla plots are also located in Valley.
8. There are policies like waiver of surcharge and delaying in payment in case of delaying in possession and effectees of IDP’s on project-to-project basis.
9. There are two major objective of each project. Quality and Delivery. In all mega projects problems like relocation and possession occurs. Terrain of Potohar is solid and uneven, which gives town planner a hectic job to do.
10. Google earth images are too old. They can lead us to specific area but cannot describe the current development of the area. (If you have slow internet connection or facing problems in downloading Google Earth software, you can directly log on to http://wikimapia.org without any download of software but the images are same).
11. Question arises about payment to Habib Rafique. If Habib Rafique is not satisfy with DHA over payment issues, why recently two companies have started DHA Tower!
12. DHA Tower is a 19 stories building located in Ph. II (Extn). It is a JV between DHA and Habib Rafique. It will be next DHA head office. Located on the edge of Expressway leading towards DHA Valley will certainly increase activities of the area. Features/Booking detail is available on various locations.
13. If DHA is no good investment for future, why in post no. 45940 Hats Off is recommended to invest in DHA Ph. II (Extn) by the same person who is writing so much against it. It raise eyebrows that what statement to rely but it also shows that investments are safe as compare to other projects.
14. DHA Valley is long term investment. Those who have not their first experience in Real Estate investment knows that 4 to 5 years are nothing in property investment. The price hike in 2004 to 2006 was unrealistic and by all means it had to adjust.
Valley is going to be a city and contains more units that whole Islamabad. New Islamabad Airport is an example of development in the region. It is situated in Pind Ranja. How much time has been consumed after the announcement of an Airport. Change of name and team are not main issues. Land was acquired by CAA in 80’s. 3600 Acre project was influenced greatly by political and economic environment. Still timeline of completion is uncertain. Valley is surely to regain its loss but it will take some time.
Delivering a plot is not main thing but it matters to deliver it in a community. In all under develop projects of DHA not only work on basic facilities are in process but Masjid, School, College, University, Hospital, Retail Centers, Community Clubs are also in the Master Plan. An example of this is the availability of 40 Kanals land available in Ph. II on main GT Road for hospital on JV basis.
In short, DHA projects can be compared with other mega projects of different societies/locations and more than compatible. I am not convincing the members here to invest but to give some clear picture. I once again recommend members/visitors to use this site only to facilitate others & for sharing of useful information and not against anyone. Even this site is running by one of DHA’s registeed property dealer.
Suggestions/comments are welcome. Thanks and Best Regards
Imran
mit1aries@hotmal.com
an Overseas Pak replied on Wednesday, January 20, 2010 01:27 PM PST
Dear Imran, I have two plot of 5 & 8 M, and have already paid 5 installments. Now the question is; keeping in mind ever growing loss on each paid installment, what we have to do, keep or sell them even on loss?
You said its long term planning, how long will you specify please.
and advice, what is the best option to invest, since I am an overseas Pakistan... Thanks |
Malik replied on Wednesday, January 20, 2010 02:57 PM PST
Mr.Imran thanks for the info but can u please put some info regarding AL GHURAIR GIGA and their projects in Phase -2 Like Platinum square and goldcrest apartments.
The construction work is stopped at the site as there are many rumors that the company leave the project and country.
I need an advice that what should i hav do now bcoz i hav own some property in these projects.
Thanks |
Malik replied on Wednesday, January 20, 2010 07:03 PM PST
a spokeman of DHA in Lahore city has said that"" the company will leave the project and country.""" |
Azad K replied on Wednesday, January 20, 2010 09:02 PM PST
Imran can you tell us how many plots will be in DHA Valley? If DHA cannot complete smaller phases launched earlier then how can we expect it to complete DHA Valley in full in the next 10 years? It is good that DHA is launch mega housing projects to overcome the housing shortage in the country and to help the working people to obtain houses within their means, but how long will it take to hand over possession of all the area? DHA should focus on completing phases where people have already paid them all the installments before launching new phases. Will the money collected by DHA from the launch of DHA Valley be used to develop DHA Valley or to fill some black hole within DHA finances or to complete earlier phases? |
Visitor replied on Wednesday, January 20, 2010 09:52 PM PST
Mr Imran thanks for the clarification. Of course you have taken a great pain in all this. May I request you to please throw some more light on the present status of development of Phase I Ext as follows:-
1. Is the development contract has awarded and is operative?
2. %age of work completed.
3. Remapping mean inclusion of Sector B & C of Ext I in Phase I proper as earlier narrated by Mr Saleem.
Thanks in advance |
atiq raja. replied on Wednesday, January 20, 2010 10:15 PM PST
agree |
Test replied on Thursday, January 21, 2010 10:37 AM PST
Fortunately this is the best time for a litmus test of DHA’s honesty!
They deleted best location plots for the sake of Expressway in Commoners’ town and promised to re-locate the affectees around the expressway at even better locations?
People are saying that they will not go in normal way as expressway is the prime place now and “Nephews & Uncles” would be blessed!
Let us see how they do it and it will prove DHA’s good thinking, if any!
I am one of the “deleted souls” and I will post my experience and I request all of the likes, to please come forward post your new locations!
It has to be a win win situation for ALL deleted plots. |
SALEEM AWAN replied on Wednesday, January 27, 2010 02:46 PM PST
Only 10% land of valley is purchased only the rest of 90 thousand kanal area is not yet purchased. So, how DHA can complete it in time. While DHA Phase-2 Extension and DHA Phase-1 Extension land is also not available and not yet purchased. land owners are not willing to sell their land to DHA while they know the importance of their land.
DHA can't start phase-1 Ext. & Phase-2 Extension.
DHA spokeman can only give false hopes of completion. He can't give you the Time of Completion because it will take minimum 10 years to Complete DHA Valley,Phase-2 extension or even more. Looking to DHA progress, The safe time period is estimated about 15 to 20 years if the complete land is available with them. |
Informer replied on Wednesday, March 3, 2010 04:17 PM PST
DHA is a biggest bull shit. |
|
|
 Saturday, August 22, 2009 12:00 PM PST Reply: 
Javaid replied on Saturday, August 22, 2009 12:44 PM PST
Dear CMY,
What are the charges other than the File Price, if I want to buy some DHA File.
Kind Regards,
Javaid Ahmed. |
friend replied on Saturday, August 22, 2009 01:54 PM PST
dear friends
i intend to buy 2 park view file-1 kanal/10 marla.
any one interested to sell .please contact on email
genuine sellers only please
hard cash.same day payment,can pay in forieg currency.
quick response will be appreciated
thanks
iqbal601@hotmail.com |
DHA Lahore Transfer Costs replied on Saturday, August 22, 2009 02:54 PM PST
Javaid sahib
Total cost for transfer that are paid on top of price that included DHA transfer fees and Govt taxes like CVT and stamp duty are
DHA 5 extension transfer cost is Rs 2.18 lacs
DHA 9-10 transfer cost is Rs 1.50 lacs
DHA 8 Park view transfer cost is Rs 2.84 lacs
DHA 8 proper transfer cost is Rs 2.25 lacs
Ch Mujahid Yasin ( CMY )
0322-4009967 |
PROGRESS replied on Saturday, August 22, 2009 04:19 PM PST
This is informative. Lots of friends always asking this question repeatedly. I suggest to please put these costs along with the rates permanently. |
Farhan replied on Sunday, August 23, 2009 06:59 AM PST
Who pays the transfer Costs, Buyer or Seller? |
Farid-UAE replied on Sunday, August 23, 2009 03:00 PM PST
Its the buyer, who pays the transfer fee, taxes etc |
Shahzad replied on Sunday, August 23, 2009 10:06 PM PST
So, if I buy a file lets say DHA 9/10, I have to pay 11% of purchase price to Govt. and 1% to real estate agent. Even if price does not go down, I will lose 12% of my investment on Day 1.
Is not this a huge disadvantage of real estate investment? |
|
|
 Friday, May 1, 2009 08:02 AM PST Reply: 
LDA HAWKSBAY SCHEME 42
Would any of the learned contributors willl share some knowledge about this location with any news about development and the future potential of this scheme-Regards and thanks for sharing
khanpervez@yahoo.com replied on Friday, May 1, 2009 10:59 AM PST
Salam MR khan;
It looks like you are an ex pat deperate to have some kind of investment in your home country.
I would suggest for karachi only go for DHA if you can afford
otherwise you just read the newspapers what is going on here.
I am stuck at home since last three days.
I am an expat to karachi use to be a wonderful place but not any more
I came to pakistan for the very same reason and has given up on karachi situation.
If u are interested in some real estate investment in USA specially new york bcz real estate market is low nowadays and ny is arecession free city i can talk to u i will be going back in july to ny
Thanks.
Pervez KHan |
SA replied on Saturday, May 2, 2009 01:45 AM PST
"NY is a recession free city"......Khan Pervez Sahib not sure which New York you are talking about but the New York I live in has been hurting like never before due to the financial turmoil on Wall Street. Property values as well as rental values have taken a serious hit because without Wall Street bonuses there are not many people who are willing to spend crazy money in New York, especially in this extremely uncertain economic environment. Please don't give definitive statements on things you have absolutely no idea about to avoid misleading people. |
khan from canada replied on Saturday, May 2, 2009 10:10 AM PST
Really appreciate the comments from khanpervex and Sa. Any other reader involved in Karachi market who can give me some input about "LYARI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY"S HAWKSBAY SCHEME 42"- Regards |
khanpervez@yahoo.com replied on Saturday, May 2, 2009 11:06 AM PST
Salam with due respect to MR SA,
I know the situation is not very good but not as bad the way un are expressing, the first reason is that u are still over there and surviving.
From investment point of view it is always good to buy when the prices are low.
What do you think the TAXI MEDALLION is now available for 1000 dollars
you can buy a property in queens for 50000 dollars.
I am a technology professional so know both the places like silicon valley and new york very well.
We can go for a fair deal lets invest 100,000 dollars in new york property and same amount in any pakistan property and lets see what would be the return after just 6 months atleast dollar appreciation will be good enough. ghora bhi hazir medan bhi hazir.
Any how i make proposals and suggestion i dont have to mislead people
Alhamdo lilah i have two degrees can easily make a living in any part of the world. A suggestion for you if it is that bad in NY leave it ASAP take a direct flight to pakistan purchase files and wait for the 9 mons of tel and the radha will dance.
Thanks.
Pervez |
Farid-UAE replied on Saturday, May 2, 2009 12:03 PM PST
The problem with us i.e "Pakistanis"s that we take every comment/view which is different from our view, personally.
I think Mr. SA has given his view and has used reasonable words to differ with Mr. khanpervez.
With due respectr to Khanpervez, i think , it is unfair to tell somebody to take first flight home if he thinks that NY is not doing good now adays.
Cant We pakistanis be respectful to other people views and "live and let live" |
khanpervez@yahoo.com replied on Sunday, May 3, 2009 02:19 PM PST
Dear Mr Farid,
I welcome healthy discussions and positive criticism. I dont get mad i just get even i had made a professional comment and a fair proposal but before my posting take a moment to read the comments made by MR SA, he has blamed me for misleading people, in response to that i had replied.
One thing more i would like to add that majority of Pakistanis are not greatful of the opportunities we get after we leave our home country that is why i believe if some thing is not beneficial why do we have to continue with it.
Dollar kamaye jao aur roye bhi jao this is the strategy adopted by most of the pakistanis living abroad.
Any how a good discussionn and exchange of views is the best work out for our brain muscle.
Thanks
Pervez Khan |
Azher syed, Helensburgh replied on Monday, May 4, 2009 06:12 AM PST
Dear Mr. Khan,
I have lived at Karachi for nearly four decades from 1965 till 1995, I am not a political activist nor I would like to incorporate any poltically motivated statement in relation to your mail.I am some one who hails from the anterior of Sindh Province and since my childhood I had been a frequent visitor to the city of Karachi and during those times karachi was infact in the "Sea of Tranquility". Rural population migrated from all corners of Pakistan in search of employment,beter life and beter civic fascilities. The local inhabitants never objected to the migration of people from other provinces but when they were threatened to turn into minority in their province and their main city (Karachi) to be controlled by MQM, that threat has seen so much blood shed that this city has been plunged into the "black hole". Back in year 1985 I decided to move to Islamabad due to security concerns. It is my personal opinion that Karachi is not a place worth visiting and what to talk of living there! Right from Hawksbay up to Steel Town and further to Thatta, Gharo on one side and Hyderabad and Dadu on the other, I have visited all these sites but brother your safety and your families safety can not be compromised in exchange for beautyful fly over and signal free corridors. Choice is yours my friend. |
khanpervez@yahoo.com replied on Monday, May 4, 2009 08:12 AM PST
Salam MR Azher,
I agree with you 100 percent. the fly overs and signal free coridoors
are built with human population on either side therefore might help in reducing population. Everyday pedistrians specially get killed on these fly overs and coridoors.
Karachi residents thinkl that they are now living in switzerland or may be someplace higher than that, most of the people have not even been to thatta when they see their past bicycles and donkey carts and now paki sarak and Suzuki car they have to go crazy.
Karachi has the worst situation in terms of law and order i have sold my apt and ready for the move.
Thanks
PK |
SA replied on Wednesday, May 6, 2009 11:21 PM PST
Khan Parvez Bhai Salaam. I was traveling for business and didn't see your reply earlier and didn't realize how much my reply had annoyed you. Great to know you have 2 degrees and you know the markets really well but in my own limited capacity I have a little bit of experience also, I am a qualified Chartered Accountant from Pakistan, an ACCA from the UK, and also got my CPA and my MBA from USA. I have worked on Wall Street myself for the last almost 10 years and have invested in the greater New York Area real estate for the last 4 years and have quite a few investments in this area. Alhamdulillah I have done very well for myself and my family. No where in my post did I mention personally being unhappy of New York. I just alluded to the general state of the US economy and specifically Wall Street and New York sentiment. By the grace of Allah my work is still fine in New York and Allah has blessed me with more money than I really need or can spend, so I do not need to get on the next flight to anywhere anytime soon. Sorry if my post offended you or questioned you in any way. I just wanted to make it clear to everyone living outside the US that the general perception that in the US "dollar darakhton par ugtey haen" and "New York is recession free" etc is just not true and people should be careful about where they spend/invest their money. |
realestate_alsamad@cyber. replied on Sunday, April 25, 2010 11:33 AM PST
I provide real estate services in Lyari Development Authority 's Scheme42 Hawksbay
So if you guys are intrested in Hawksbay do give me a call
My company (with the permission and grant of CDGK )has officially designed Maps of Hawkbsay Scheme 42
My numbers are +92-321-2264064
office +92-21-34940582
EMAIL :realestate_alsamad@cyber.net.pk
Regards
Ali Muhammad Tayyab
AL-SAMAD ESTATE |
|
| 8154) | |
| dha8 |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Saturday, January 10, 2009 03:01 PM PST Reply: 
bubble is bursting again soon
dear cmy
its heared that dha does not have all land for phase 8,and there are still big pockets of village population in the existing planned land
area across the barki road is included in phase 8,so fews file holders will get the plot there
dha is proposing to fix the development charges @ 15 lacs per kanal
parkview ballotting is arranged in march09.
its also heared that dha authorities are thinking to shift its next phases/8,9,10 on the otherside of the city-raiwind road,as there is highly likely possiblity that dha is taking over dha rahber.
moreover worsening security n border conditions ,its expected that not only dha but all the realestate prices are going to fall significantly ,very soon.
please comment
thanks
Jamil replied on Saturday, January 10, 2009 03:38 PM PST
Mr. dha8
Whats wrong now that prices have started to recover have you mised the boat to purchase a file of this phase. Now you are trying to scare people in trying to depress prices again. This is the oldest trick in the book.
What evidences have you got to support your negative claims. Also the reason for phase 8 not being balloted could be due to the low pricesof DHA 7 and once this has recovered and prices return to normal maybe then is the time to ballot 8 after and established constructed phase 7 this claim is just my opinion and not based on any fact. As some of us tell the truth. |
Jameel replied on Wednesday, January 14, 2009 12:11 AM PST
You will continue listening Rumors till things will materlize. But DHA 8 development charges 13 to 14 Lac is realistic figure if it is balloted in 2009. Taking into account 9 lac asked 2.5 ys Back for Phase 7 and 6 Lac asked for phase 6 3.5 years back, so just multiply with at least 1.5 every 2 years.
I think other than land issue main reason for DHA not to ballot phase 8 is Property Slum, if they Ballot and ask the development charges 16 lac the Price of DHA 8 plots will nose dive. To save the interest of investors may be DHA wnat that DHA 6, and 7 be absorbed and prices to recover. |
Hamid replied on Wednesday, January 14, 2009 09:48 AM PST
"its heared that dha does not have all land for phase 8"
"still big pockets of village population"
"across the barki road is included in phase 8"
"dha is proposing to fix the development charges @ 15 lacs per kanal"
"shift its next phases/8,9,10 on the otherside of the city-raiwind road"
"moreover worsening security n border conditions"
" realestate prices are going to fall significantly ,very soon"
Lets scare every one so you could buy a DHA 8 at lower price because you dont have enough money to buy DHA 8 now.
May be you should add more scary and made up stuff to disappoint others. This stuff is not beliveable and readers here are not idiots like you to belive it.
If you are so disappointed in DHA and in real estate investment what are you doing here on this web site about property. |
Pardesi, Jeddah replied on Wednesday, January 14, 2009 10:13 AM PST
Even 35+ lac is not a bad price to get into a dea in dha 8 as the momentum is picking up. If you can figure out from the press release of dha for ph VI deadline for construction set at Sep 2011; lets assume 2013 will be set for Ph VII, then what you can foresee current prices of Ph VIII + it forms a link to ph VI & VII. 34+15=49 or 50 lac for a developed plot in ph VIII can fetch gain upto 30-40 lacs in 3-5 years or even more.
Regarding other scary news: substantiate your claims with facts & sources. |
|
|
 Friday, November 7, 2008 08:33 PM PST Reply: 
arsalan replied on Friday, November 7, 2008 08:54 PM PST
Thank God I didn't invest in DHA Phase 7 two years ago :) |
alpha replied on Friday, November 7, 2008 09:05 PM PST
Dear Arsalan Sahab
AoA
Since 2007, DHA Lahore Phase 7 prices have bore the systematic Pakistani real estate market risk (beta of 1). I am not sure if you would have done better then phase 7 DHA investment, if you had invested in any other 7 -10 year real estate investment in Pakistan in 2007. However, there are always investors who have information/market access advantage over typical passive investors.
regards |
Mazhar replied on Friday, November 7, 2008 09:13 PM PST
Despite losses and extremely bad market DHA phase 8 Parkview 10 marla files have gained nearly 20% in last six months. Parkview kanal files have not lost. All other DHA plots, files and almost all other societies are down considerably. |
arsalan replied on Friday, November 7, 2008 09:37 PM PST
alpha may be my words were a bit harsh but I am extreamly stunned to see the price range from 28 to 50 lac. That was the level exactly 2 years from now and as far as investing is concerned, ALLAH TALA Ka bohat shukar hai that my investment from then has doubled in value. I was looking to invest 7.2 million rupees and where I invested has doubled in this time period and has not gone down in todays market. |
alpha replied on Friday, November 7, 2008 09:57 PM PST
Dear Mazhar Sahab,
AOA
DHA Parkview pre-balloted files are a different class of investment then from Phase 7 post-balloted plots, from time-to-maturity and risk (risk that was there in 2007) point of view. There returns have been higher. Arsalan Sahab, congragulations!
regards |
arsalan replied on Friday, November 7, 2008 11:30 PM PST
Thank you alpha sahib |
Jameel replied on Friday, November 7, 2008 11:54 PM PST
It is almost lowest level of DHA 7 Plots in last many year, same rate came abut 2 ys Back when Market was lowest and phase 8 File was sold as low as 28,29. Phase 7 at this time is surest and much undervalued product,
I dont know where arsalan Doubled his money in last 2 years. If it is Park view File there is reason of DHA take over, which at that time was a bet only. Parkview files can lose the price if One of the following things happen
If they are not Balloteed for Long time
Their location is acroess the Barki road near BRB,
Or their Developmet Charges are too much, Take the Example of DHA 7 in which File was 35 lac 3 Months before Ballot, And Now you are getting sure locatin average plot, with development underway in 24+9 lac Like, Like 11,12 Lac saving in 2 years. DHA 7 Location was not unexpected, same thing can happen in Parkview File as well. |
Usman replied on Saturday, November 8, 2008 08:59 PM PST
Dear CMY
The rates u provided for DHAI phase 2 extension based on Blocks is something confusing... as we dont have map and balloting stiil needs to be done... Can u plzz explain this...
Regards
Usman |
|
| 8152) | |
| FT |
| f_trn@yahoo.com | | Phone:9710501142843 | City & Country: Dubai | |
 Saturday, October 18, 2008 10:06 AM PST Reply: 
Plot Prices
To stay optimistic, I believe plot prices will rise in Pakistan due to following reasons :
- Panic with Stock Markets
- Lack of trust in Banking sector
- Flat prices for a long time, upward cycle has to kick in. It will be nice if someone can advise on realestate cycles in Pakistan? I believe one was in mid ninties and other soon after 9/11.
- People who don't have options to move o'seas have no option but to invest in Pakistan.
- Lack of well planned, secure housing socities in Pakistan
- Ruppee devaluation against US$. At the end, all prices have to adjust accordingly unfortunately.
- Real estate investment has turned to be safer investment in the long term.
- Weaker rupee opens and opportunity for overseas Pakistani's to buy something for eventual return. Sooner or later this will happen
At the end of the day, people who could hold their investments turn out to be the winners. We should only hope that conditions in Pakistan improve because without law and order and war situation, it will be a chaos.
New Observer replied on Saturday, October 18, 2008 10:59 PM PST
Dear Ft,
Please Please hold the property for another 4-5 years, as even after 5 years you can max. get few thousand paki rupee of profit in real estate because of recession.
so please hold the property forever, and let the buyer go some where else.
enjoy!!! |
FT replied on Sunday, October 19, 2008 10:29 AM PST
Kindly advise other avenues for investments in Pakistan? |
|
| 8151) | |
| Hamid |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Friday, August 15, 2008 09:21 PM PST Reply: 
Declining Ruppee and Real estate investment.
It am astonished to see that 1 dollar is worth 76.45 today. Does it really make sense to convert US dollar to Ruppee and buy a plot in Pakistan. A typical plot costs about 40 lacs. So decline in value of 1 ruppee against a USD make you lose 40,000 ruppees.
I am not sure if I should hold off and wait to buy a plot at this moment.
Please suggest in this very uncertain situation.
May God help Pakistan get through this tough time.
Expat replied on Friday, August 15, 2008 10:02 PM PST
Invest for long term only. Rupee may down further in the short term |
Jameel replied on Friday, August 15, 2008 11:03 PM PST
For short Term it does not make sense, but if you have to convert some portion of your portfolio in realestae sector [should be about 60% for gulf settled like me], next couple of months will be best time to do so as it is "enry time" to invest in realestate. Some of propeties like in DHA Lhr and DHAi you are getting at 1/3 of peak price [Rupee Vlaue adjusted], As with lower rupee value forign currency remittences are at its record level. Eventually most of this will be invested in real estate sector.
But buy only if you find propery at good price, and in underpriced areas with good potential. To me it is right time to buy in Phase 7 and DHA islamabad Plots. But Traget should be 5 ys not less. |
IMRAN replied on Saturday, August 16, 2008 12:48 AM PST
DEAR CMY SB....
KEEP THE NEW MAP ...WHICH ONE U MAKE IN FLASH...
PLEASE KEEP IN FRONT IN THIS SITE SOMEWHERE... |
CMY replied on Saturday, August 16, 2008 11:41 AM PST
Imran bhai I am still uploading and fixing many broken links for these new maps. For now you can find all links at:
http://www.lahorerealestate.com/maps
I will put them on front page when all map links are working properly |
|
|
 Saturday, July 12, 2008 11:02 AM PST Reply: 
Investment in Dubai
Can someone please tell me the minimum amount needed to invest in Dubai and from which one can also get a residential Visa.
I have heard that there are two types of investments in Dubai,
1) Rental investments, where when you buy a flat and put it on rent and receive the payment in Pakistan, which is quite large, 60-80 thousand per month.
2) When you buy a property and leave it so it can appreciate in value.
Any advice will be appreciated.
Info replied on Saturday, July 12, 2008 12:21 PM PST
Dubai is only good for tourism not suitable for residence. That only if you have very deep pocket. Recently UAE immigration minister declared that residence visa is not guaranteed with real estate investment. Also important to keep in mind the residence visa is temporary (normally 3 years, renewable) and is just valid for residence not for work. Residence and work are two very different things. |
Info replied on Saturday, July 12, 2008 12:38 PM PST
Residence visa will be issued to original buyers only upon completion of property if they still own it. That means you cannot get a residence visa until your property is finished and if you bought it from orininal allotee you cannot claim any visa right from the selling company. Where applicable the real estate company you bought property from will assist, and charge you for processing of visa. There are also UAE govt fees. The small real estate companies in UAE have not good track record regarding this. But large developers like Damac and Emaar are more responsible and cooperative. |
Property replied on Saturday, July 12, 2008 01:35 PM PST
the topic was "types of investment" not "types of visas" |
Sbaig replied on Saturday, July 12, 2008 01:40 PM PST
There are thousands of Dubai property related web sites where you can find solutions to your querries regading Dubai property 'jungle'. Please spare this site. thanks. |
Info replied on Saturday, July 12, 2008 01:54 PM PST
Mr property you should read the first line of sasasd post again. |
|
| 8149) | |
| Habib |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Tuesday, June 17, 2008 05:07 PM PST Reply: 
too much similarity in rates in June 06,07,08
There is striking similarity of rates in June 06,07,08 It it a chance? seasonal variation? or signs of stabilty of Market?? Food for thought
Market Pulse at 6 Pm Lahore TimeTuesday June 09, 2006
DHA Lahore Phase 7 @ 33.90 to 34.15 Under selling pressure
DHA Lahore Phase 8 @ 40.90 to 41.10 Under selling pressure
DHA Lahore Phase 9-10 @ 19.15 to 19.35 Under selling pressure
DHA phase 5 @ 75 to 138 lacs
DHA phase 6 @ 50 lacs to 75 lacs
*** Updated: Monday, June 11, 2007 3:00 PM ***
LRE Market Pulse ( Rates You Can Trust )
• DHA Lahore Phase 5 Ext: Buyer(s) at 33.00 Seller(s) at 33.75 Lacs
• DHA Lahore Phase 8 Allocation: Buyer(s) at 40.50 Seller(s) at 41.00 Lacs
• DHA Lahore Phase 9/10 Allocation: Buyer(s) at 17.30 Seller(s) at 17.40 Lacs
• State Life Phase 2 Proper, 8-Paid, 1-Kanal: Buyer(s) at 11.95 Seller(s) at 12.05 Lacs
• State Life Phase 2 Membership, 6-Paid, 1-Kanal: Buyer(s) at 8.95 Seller(s) at 9.05 Lacs
• Bahria Town Phase 9, 3-Paid, 10-Marla: Buyer(s) at 1.74 Seller(s) at 1.76 Lac
• Bahria Town Phase 9, 2-Paid, 10-Marla: Buyer(s) at 1.23 Seller(s) at 1.25 Lac
For less frequently changed rates in other housing societies/cities please visit:
Lahore Real Estate Market Pulse at 04.30 Pm June 9, 2008
DHA Lahore Phase 5 Extension. Allocation: Buyer(s) at 33.25 Sellers(s) at 33.50
DHA Lahore Phase 8 Allocation Against land: Buyer(s) at 42.85 Seller(s) at 43 Lacs
DHA Lahore Phase 9/10 Allocation Against land: Buyer(s) at 18.35 Seller(s) at 18.40 Lacs
Parkview-DHA-8 Lahore 1 kanal allocation file Buyer(s) at 30.60 Seller(s) at 30.75 Lacs.
Park view-DHA-8 10 Marla allocation file against Land Buyer(s) at 19.30 Seller(s)19.35 lacs.
Parkview-DHA-8 10 Marla allocation file against PV plots Buyer(s) at 18.80 Seller(s)at 18.95 Lacs.
Oversees Pakistani replied on Tuesday, June 17, 2008 08:27 PM PST
Very interesting information. If we take dha phase 7 prices, we could argue:
1) The prices in June 2006 were inflated
2) The prices in June 2008 are depressed
3) A combination of both above
I would agree with last explaination. The prices after two years can't be the same when there is a considerable change in terms of development work. Two years back there was nothing and now we can see lots of development work nearing completion in soon time. |
khggjh replied on Tuesday, June 17, 2008 09:43 PM PST
So that means that the poor people who have bought DHA files for the past 3 years have suffered a loss due to the not rising of prices and if they did it was only a few las where as even in a small society on Canal road increased many lacs. |
ahsan replied on Tuesday, June 17, 2008 11:23 PM PST
Yeah reason is that since 2005 market is down and prices are hoovering almost at the same rate. |
Observer replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 08:39 AM PST
It means the people who have invested in DHA has suffered loss.
30/40 lacs in 2005 are not equal to 30/40 lacs in 2008. The inflation has hit the pak rupees badly. |
GG replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 08:57 AM PST
There is one bird called "Saturation". Madness for DHA has saturated resulting in stagnation of prices. |
Obs replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 10:46 AM PST
Habib Sb, where did you pull out this data from. Is it available from any link within this website? Thanks. Its a wonderful info. |
Habib replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 11:46 AM PST
This data is pulled from old posts by CMY you can goto old post [right up]
I think DHA is cheaper for people who are buying now, any time soon recovery can start as prices will not stay here for very long time, No body know Right time to buy, But there is no big chance of losing in figures if you enter the market at this point, seasonal trend indicates that prices are lowest in Octobers, DHA 8 ballot will not be big gain for Kanal File holders unless they get better locations, but 10 M may gain and if Park view is settled with this ballot they may gain as well,
Logic can be after this mini 10 M "mini ballot" in Park view just 20 days Back for army officers, main DHA 8 Ballot should not be soon [otherwise why they should not wait couple of Months]. But an argument can be they want to give time to army officers to offload their plots on Higher rates before main lot comes in. In fact no Logic works for DHA they are extremely secret and dodging. |
Investor replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 12:10 PM PST
Do not blame DHA for everything. You have very limited and flawed knowledge. Your tone is also unfair and biased. Only civilians got plots in this Parkview ballot. You are making claims based on assumptions or wrong information. I can give you tens of examples of ordinary people. Some of them are overseas. These days they are getting intimation letters of plot numbers by mail. In the ballot, files against land were given priority according to the agreement with the land providers. Every plot holder who got the plot and selling in market or asking for assessment is a civilian.
As DHA arranges more land they will keep doing the ballots for Parkview because they have liability to provide plots. Since there are so many files and everybody wants the plots as soon as possible, as the DHA gets any land cleared around Parkview or Air Ave they do the ballot. This process will continue. That is why I pointed it out well in time as best investment even in the worst case scenario. For people who got plots it was the best case scenario. Others who have not got a plot in this ballot stand best chance in next ballot. Even in the worst case scenrio any 10 marla plot of DHA @ around 21 lacs plus development charges is certainly best investment (compared with other options in and out of DHA) even if the plot is given after 5 years, and even if the location is across Barki road. That is worst case scenario. Every other scenario is better than that. |
Questions replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 01:13 PM PST
Dear Investor,
There are few questions which need your expert comments:
1) How do you see Real Estate Business in Pakistan till July, 2009 keeping in view current social, economical and political aspects?
2) How do you see the future of DHA 9/10? To be precise, where do you see Phase 9/10 in 2013 and 2018 respectively?
3) What are your views about Statelife II? Where do you see this in July, 2009 and 2013?
You are requested to reply these questions because of the wealth of experience and analytical skill you possess. This will help many people around.
Jazak Allah |
Investor replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 04:37 PM PST
Each of your questions requires very detailed answers. I am really sorry that due to lack of time I have to give brief answers:
1. Real Estate outlook in Pakistan for next one year is neither "Rosy" nor it is "Damned". There are several political and economical uncertainties. Investors hate uncertainties, and blurry pictures. However, if you do your homework and be very selective you can spot good investments. DO NOT INVEST FOR VERY SHORT TERM (less than a year). Real estate is not suitable for short term investment. Select a few good instruments and Invest for medium to long term (3 to 10 years, or even more). Just sleep on it as long as you are convinced it is still good investment. If the price goes up too fast get out, and switch. If fundamentals (Macro and Micro. Direct and Indirect) change, you must re-assesses your investment.
If you do it right your investment in real estate can be significantly more yielding than other investment options in Pakistan. (Of course if you contribute to something more productive, that is better. But if you have spare money, and need to invest somewhere, real estate investment done with proper research, is one of the most viable options).
It's all a game of RISK and REWARD. There are FOUR combinations:
a. LOW-RISK & LOW-REWARD
b. LOW-RISK & HIGH-REWARD
c. HIGH-RISK & LOW-REWARD
d. HIGH-RISK & HIGH-REWARD
A smart investor always looks for LOW-RISK & HIGH REWARD investments. Such investments are relatively easier to spot in Bear or stable markets, and hard to spot in Bull (hot) markets. You have to have an eye to spot and act with good timing. TIMING is very important in real estate investments. When you know that something fundamentally strong is beaten up too hard and everyone is selling, that is "THE BEST TIME TO BUY". When everyone is a buyer, and price has been inflated too much more than worth, that is the "TIME TO SELL".
2. DHA 9/10 is one of the LOW-RISK & HIGH-REWARD investments. It has very accessible location. It starts very close to DHA phase 4 and 5 and ends 1/2 KM before Hadiara drain. This phase will have best access from Ferozpur road. Today it is around 18.50 Lacs. It's hard to give future projections in Pakistan, but in my opinion in 2013 it should be somewhere between 45 and 65 Lacs. In 2018 (10 years from now) it should be somewhere between 1.10 and 1.50 Crore. All prices are excluding development charges.
3. You have asked about Statelife phase 2? There are some fundamental weaknesses in this investment. Although things can improve/change over time, in the current status there are other clearly better investments. Handling of a project of the magnitude of Statelife phase 2 is beyond the capabilities of their current management. The best case scenario for Statelife phase 2 is it will be merged with DHA 9/10, but when and at what terms, is not clear. The worst case scenario is status quo for at least 5 to 10 years. I have no personal or business interest in Statelife scheme or its management, but based on my observation and knowledge, in the best interest of everyone who holds investment in Statelife, I would suggest that Statelife members along with dealers should push for a management overhaul, otherwise the outlook is bleak. In my opinion investment in Statelife phase 1 is better than phase 2 (I am just comparing the two, not suggesting phase 1). In my humble opinion here is the breakdown of Statelife phase 1 and phase 2:
a. Statelife Phase 1 (5 Marla) @ 15 to 17 Lacs: LOW-RISK & LOW-REWARD
b. Statelife Phase 1 (10 Marla) @ 18 to 22 Lacs: LOW-RISK & HIGH-REWARD
c. Statelife Phase 1 (1 Kanal) @ 27 to 45 Lacs: LOW-RISK & LOW-REWARD
d. Statelife Phase 2 (5 Marla) @ 6 to 7 Lacs: UNCLEAR-RISK & LOW-REWARD
e. Statelife Phase 2 (10 Marla) @ 8 to 10 Lacs: HIGH-RISK & LOW-REWARD
f. Statelife Phase 2 (1 Kanal) Cat 1 (low 'own') @ 11 to 12.50 Lacs: LOW-RISK & LOW-REWARD
g. Statelife Phase 2 (1 Kanal) Cat 2 (High 'own') @ 12.50 to 21 Lacs: HIGH-RISK & LOW-REWARD
( P.S. Phase 2 Proper files have more risk due to high 'own' than Membership files. ) |
Habib replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 05:14 PM PST
Dear investor I understand either you selling DHA 8, 10 Merla files or You have invested all your life saving in that. That is why you are becoming loud speaker for DHA 10 merla files.
In past 35 ys DHA never balloted Block by Block, niether they give Developed or semi developed plots in ballot.[which they did in this "Mini Ballot"], Your assumption are entirely baseless and speculative. And if according to DHA will be ballting Phase 8 bit by bit then it will be the worst disaster. |
Investor replied on Wednesday, June 18, 2008 05:27 PM PST
Dear Habib you have no knowledge of DHA and its ballots (there are small ballots going on in DHA all over the year for new affidavits issued against recent land given to DHA, generally whenever there are 100 allocations to be balloted. That is different from a major phase ballot. A lot of times these ballots are against chunks of land given to DHA at provider's terms to do the ballot within certain time. And it's a routine to get developed plots where there are developed plot still with DHA. There are still some in DHA 1 to 5). But, since you pretend to know a lot, making assumptions and inferring conclusions from those assumptions, I don't think it will be of any benefit for anyone to engage in a debate with you on this.
Regards,
(P.S. it is because of "extremely knowlegable" and "receptive" friends like you that I avoid writing on this forum. A lot of us just don't deserve to know. My posts are basically intended for those who deserve.)
=== Bar Samaa-e-Raast Har Kas Cheez Naist ===
=== Tauma-e Har Murghke Injeer Naist === |
Questions replied on Thursday, June 19, 2008 06:24 AM PST
Dear Investor,
Thank you so much for your reply to my questions. Your analysis is very logical and comments are very realistic, I must say. This insight into real estate business will definitely help many people like me.
As I have already felt that you avoid writing on this forum, I will appreciate if you could drop an email on my following address: orientadv@yahoo.com. My intentions are not to keep you bombarded with further questions, but to get your sincere and honest opinion whenever I am investing my hard earned money into real estate (which is usually done once a year).
Thank you again for taking out some valuable moments from your precious time to reply my post.
Regards |
adil_sap_fi_co@yahoo.com replied on Saturday, June 21, 2008 05:52 PM PST
Dear Investor
It would be appreciable if you criticise the below explanation:
a. LOW-RISK & LOW-REWARD - Good Developer, Stable & Market with no or low Development in the Economy
b. LOW-RISK & HIGH-REWARD - Good Developer, Stable Market with Development in the Economy & favourable Foreign Investment
c. HIGH-RISK & LOW-REWARD - Avg. Developer, Volatile Market without Development in the Economy & unfavourable Foreign Investment
d. HIGH-RISK & HIGH-REWARD - Avg. Developer, volatile Market with Development in the Economy & favourable Foreign Investment
I would appreciate if you can provide me your email address as well |
|
|
 Friday, June 6, 2008 05:44 PM PST Reply: 
I am an overseas Pakistani. Can some of the experts on this very useful forum guide me about real estate investment opportunities in Islamabad?
I would like to see my investments grow, together with a peace of mind that my investements are safe, secure and above all genuine. This investment can be considered a long term one as I am no hurry to sale the plot or even considering building my own house on it.I have the range of between 3 to 4 million PKR. I heard that DHAI Phase 2 Ext, and other phases are good options? In Phase 2 Extension what are the range of prices these days? How about Overseas sector of DHAI? I have heard that prices in Overseas sector are higher than Phase2 Ext though they are in close vicinity, I guess. Why the prices are higher in Overseas sector? Is there a reason?
Is this a good time to invest or one should wait till Budget or at least until political scenario of the country becomes stable? How is the market these days? Bullish or Bearish? I would appreciate valuable guidance fom the forum experts. Kind Regards to all.
ch replied on Friday, June 6, 2008 06:39 PM PST
dhai phase 2 ext ex commeners town is the best choice right now.price range is 3 to 4.5 millions inclusive all.it is safe and will be ready in a years time |
Malik replied on Friday, June 6, 2008 09:57 PM PST
G-13 is very good if you are planning to keep for some time. A 10 marla plot ranges from 5 to 6 million. This is part of Islamabad. |
Ahmed replied on Friday, June 6, 2008 10:36 PM PST
How about G-15, is it a good investment for long term? Please let me know what is the price range in this sector for plots of 1 kanal, 14,10 marla. How you compare it to the DHA phase II extension ex-commoners town in long run both location wise and future potential.
Please guide me and thanks for your help. |
|
|
 Friday, May 23, 2008 12:58 PM PST Reply: 
I am on overseas Pakistani. Can some of the experts on this very useful forum guide me about real estate investment opportunities in Islamabad?
I would like to see my investments grow, together with a peace of mind that my investements are safe, secure and above all genuine. This investment can be considered a long term one as I am no hurry to sale the plot or even considering building my own house on it.I have the range of between 3 to 4 million PKR. I heard that DHAI Commoner's town, and other phases are good options? In Commoner's town what are the range of prices these days? How about Overseas sector of DHA? I have heard that prices in Overseas sector are higher than Commoner's town though they are in close vicinity, I guess. Why the prices are higher in Overseas sector? Is there a reason?
Is this a good time to invest or one should wait till Budget or at least until political scenario of the country becomes stable? How is the market these days? Bullish or Bearish? I would appreciate valuable guidance fom the forum experts. Kind Regards to all.
|
|
 Thursday, April 10, 2008 07:31 PM PST Reply: 
ASHRAF again further to my post 37805
..i am really thank ful of CMY for his reply and input.
..i donot advice CMY to take medicine,but i will try PROZAC to please my CMY.
..i also thank for CMY for using good words for me,this shows his depth in his business.
..the property is at same price for last 2 years ,and it will remain the same,the prices were raised fakely by the property dealers
..there is nothing special in DHA to pay for such high price
..policies are rapidly changing
..old phases of DHA will rise only and not the new one,s
..plots of DHA are more in market than the buyers,it will go on increasing day by day,a time is near when u will see more than 50000 or more plot in market,do all have price of 1 crore or more,practcally not possible to digest,any how CMY may be in dreams
..its the false raise in price by different people to make the life in this country miserable for an ordinary man.
..lot of the message was sent to caution the lay-man
..i have enough plot in DHA with experience enough to discuss
..this is a discussion forum,every one has right to say for the betterment of all.
..CMY has really minded i donot why but my brother 'TRUTH IS ALWAYS BITTER",,for the bitter truth i do oplogise and in vite others to participate in this debate
..with due respect for all
..your ASHRAF KHAN
..
Murtaza replied on Thursday, April 10, 2008 07:56 PM PST
Dear Ashraf Khan Sahib
Your message is quite interesting and does hold some fact, but there are some issues which I have and need to clear up.
At present it is very difficult to purchase a kanal plot in a decent scheme for less than 50-60 lacs. DHA is much superior than all other socities and that is a fact which is generaly accepted by all.
I know that DHA have alot of plots but I think that many people would rather have DHA in there address than any other society.
I believe that the DHA prices might stabilise for awhile then increase when political issues are resolved. The amount of work that is being carried out in phase 7 is immense, and will enevitably increase prices.
As far as DHA 8 proper and 9/10 files they might suffer if ballot is not held soon and with the looming politcal situations might downturn the prices.
I believe that once DHA 8 is balloted it will be developed as a matter of priority and prices will increase dramatically as it is surronded by all developed socities.
I would like to say what you think about comments that I have just made and everyone is entitled to what they think. |
Sammy replied on Thursday, April 10, 2008 08:34 PM PST
Dear Ashraf Khan,
Your comments have some validity (only if you are living in a box). From a pure investor's get rich in 6 months point of view, you make a lot of sense and you should not invest in DHA at all.
You are right about the high number of plots in DHA but let me introduce the concept of 'population growth' to you. DHA as a developer has great vision by planning for the next 15 years. If they didnt plan Phase 9/10 (which might be populated in 10 years), DHA will look like Androon-e-shehr.
Lets review, you dont have a problem with DHA Phase I-V as they are populated so lets put that a side. Phase VI possession of plots have been given and in 2 years, it will have the same number of houses as you see today in Phase V because where else can you find a ready to build land for about 60 lacs, mind you with the DHA name attached to it. In about 2 years, you will be able to start building a house in Phase VII. I think at 40 lacs thats a hell of a buy. Phase VI and VII, with Broadway opened will be as fast a drive away from the airport as any other DHA phase. Files of DHA VIII will be up or down based on speculations but when it is balloted and developed, you cant argue with the location. It probably will be the most expensive piece of land in DHA after being developed so at current files prices, there is plenty of room for profit. Patience is the key in real estate investment and never invest the money that you cant afford to invest. |
Saqib replied on Thursday, April 10, 2008 08:41 PM PST
Ashraf Khan
To say the least, your comments and advice is as much a bundle of words as is of CMY .You do not back your prediction in any more scientific way than him.
Show us your past. How far were you on the target in your past predictions.
The information given by CMY is typically on macro level.Which I have found mostly reasonable. I have my self been a beneficiary of that. As for a particular plot or location or deal a definitive research and search should be done by buyers.
Except for investment for speculative purposes, if you have a macro information you cannot be very much wrong.
Unfortunately I smell a fair amount of jealousy in your post. Why don't you come out a competitive web page and promote such a discussion on that. |
Jameel UAE replied on Saturday, April 12, 2008 12:57 AM PST
I did not want to jump in discussion, but I feel most of investors of DHA are overseas Pakistani who have Surplus money and due to inflation their money is burning in fast pace like some 6% per year [even if they keep in Dollar], they invest in plots to safe guard the money. They have no intend to make houses in DHA. As a matter of fact price In DHA may be slowly rising due to this demand [of investment], Regarding housing and construction. In 10 ys Time DHA5 and 6 and some blocks of 7 may be a populated [50 to 60%]. But full phase 7,8 and 9,10 May be populated in 20+ years. But it does not mean even if they are not populated their price will not rise. But in short term price will fall as indicated by CMY as well. |
|
| 8145) | |
| Rana |
| | City & Country: USA | |
 Thursday, March 27, 2008 06:14 PM PST Reply: 
Biyana - Please Explain
I am an occasional visitor to this site and have passive real estate investment in Lahore. Since I am more of a buy & hold kind of person, I do not watch the market as closely. I am aware that it has gone up significantly and rapidly since early this year.
Off and on I read CMY and others talk about “Plots on Biyana” or “Biyana Plots” as being available in the market. I have read posts where folks talk derogatorily about dealers trading in such plots. Can some one shed more light on this side of business? Is it speculative buying by making a down payment and getting a month or more to make full payment or loose the down payment? Somewhat like Call Options on stock exchange. How does it really work? If property dealers themselves deal in this kind of speculative buying, does it not have the effect of rapid price increase, because anytime there is a genuine buyer in the market the dealers will steer them towards biyana plots they themselves have a financial interest in? And a genuine seller is squeezed out of the market. Your thoughts are appreciated.
|
|
 Monday, March 24, 2008 01:44 AM PST Reply: 
Realtors, investors all geared up to boost property business
The real estate investors and dealers are flexing their muscles to fuel up the standstill property business in the metropolis after government formation in the country.
The holding of elections could not heat up the market's situation as the realtors and investors expected it but it is being hoped that with the formation of government, the real estate market will be active again.
Real estate analyst, Ovais Sohail, told Daily Times that the market had not taken bullish turn after elections but there were some positive buying activities witnessed in commercial side by corporate sectors. "The market will take a significant bounce in the next one or two months as strong sentiments prevail among investors' circles," he told and added "particularly the Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) will attract big investors whenever their confidence boosts."
Mr Shoail, who is also Chief Operating Officer of Pak Real Estate, a local real estate research house, told that a number of foreign developers and construction companies have been waiting to enter in Pakistan's real estate market because of the high returns of as compared to other countries of the region except Dubai. He added that the majority of the foreign developers are interested to invest in Punjab, as they believed that the provincial government would be more stable there as compared to other provinces.
He mentioned the pace investment in Pakistan is continuing at Dubai's real estate market as the confidence of local investors is yet to be restored.
The property business has witnessed a prolong passiveness for last year as the prevailing political uncertainties coupled with law and order situation deteriorated in the country causing negative impact across the board in all investment-favorite posh societies of the major cities.
A retailer of Gulistan-e-Johar area, Syed Mabroor, said even transactions of the properties are very slow contributing to the decline in prices in some localities, now we (real estate agents and brokers) are closely observing the government formation and ready to play our game in the market. We have been advising the investors not to sell their property with low returns so they have also been waiting for resuming of trading activities. And when all the investors involve are re-active in the trading, the market will be skyrocketing, he added.
He said the transactions and values have been increased after elections and hoped that it will take more pace in the next month.
Vice President Real Estate and Construction's sub-committee, Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPPCI), Munir Sultan said that the local developers and constructors have been adopting wait-and-see policy since the holding of the elections but now they are all set to announce their residential and commercial projects.
He said that some developers had announced their housing projects and societies after elections but they are not getting positive response. He told that a big number of projects will start their booking activities in the next one or two months. As far as Gwadar real estate is concerned, the resident retailer, Saeed Baloch, told that the property's transaction has gripped the momentum since the commencement of Gwadar seaport. He added that the prices of the commercial and residential plots have increased sharply for the last one week.
But, some realtors are still very pessimistic about political and governing situation of the country, they said that the rift between elected assembly and President and movement to restore deposed judges are yet to be solved which may impact the real estate market.
Courtesy: Daily Times
|
|
 Tuesday, February 5, 2008 11:30 PM PST Reply: 
REIT - Kya hai ye
lately i have been hearing alot about this, REIT, i know it stands for real estate investment trust, but what is this, i have never heard of it before what is it for.
thank you
Khan replied on Wednesday, February 6, 2008 12:25 AM PST
Check the website below for detail info on REIT.
http://www.brecorder.com/index.php?id=597123 |
Chief Guest replied on Wednesday, February 6, 2008 08:30 AM PST
Pakistan corporate regulator plans to introduce a specialised mutual fund to help regulate the real estate business by bringing it under the umbrella of stock trading, said a top official. The Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) has decided to bring in the Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) as an alternative asset class in the country.
The REITs is a specialised mutual fund that sells like a stock and primarily invests in the real estate. It is usually a company that offers common shares to the public. A REIT stock is similar to any other one that represents ownership in an operating business.
A mutual fund is a form of collective investments that pools money from many investors in stocks, bonds, short-term money market instruments, and/or other securities. Salman Ali Shaikh, the commissioner at the specialised companies division of the SECP, told Business Recorder on Thursday that a draft to introduce such a regulation has been finalised.
The commission, he said, has now publicised the proposed parameters to seek public opinion. "We have placed it on the web site and (we) will start writing about 100 letters to concerned individuals and organisations to improve the draft," Shaikh added.
The SECP will then finalise and formally introduce the regulation within 30 days. The reasonable input from the public as well as experts will be incorporated in the draft. The SECP will initially introduce the REITs in three major cities - Islamabad, Karachi and Lahore. Other towns will then be included gradually. Potential investors will have to buy land for floating the REIT fund.
According to a document Shaikh provided to this writer, the REIT Regulations, 2007 will help increase the inflows of foreign direct investment (FDI) into Pakistan. The foreign investors are at the moment reluctant to enter the unstructured market especially where real estate scandals have caused mistrust. Experts believe it will also discourage the sale and purchase of land only on papers. The document says domestic investors will follow a structured route under the REITs framework.
The combination of an equity security and real estate will offer an alternative asset class to investors. Shaikh said amendments made in the 1984 Company Ordinance through the Finance Bill, 2007 empowered the SECP to make such regulations under its regulatory jurisdiction.
Pakistan, Ali claimed, would become the first country to introduce the stock trading of real estate businesses among the so-called emerging economies. At the moment, this system is in place only in the United Stated, Europe and parts of Asia. Rapidly growing economies like India, Vietnam and Philippines still lack such a law. |
|
| 8142) | |
| jnzi |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Monday, January 28, 2008 02:52 PM PST Reply: 
Some interesting ponits open for debate
1- Why has the recent correction in global equities not affected Pakistan???
This is quite strange for me!!
This suggests that the Pakistani market stands "corrected" already and / or the international funds do not have a significant stake in the Pakistani market. The money in KSE appears to be more local.
2- The Pakistani property market is stagnent for the last three years - DHA values are sitting where they slid to after march 05 correction.
The Pakistani expatriates are sending 6 Billion of foreign exchange money every year. What assets this money is going into?
It was probably bank savings and KSE last year. Where will this go in 2008?
3- The Pakistani economy has no significant export / competitive advantage to speak of, unlike India, China, Brazil, Malaysia etc, so the stagnation of Pakistani exports is understandable.
The Pakistani ruppee has been supported by the strong inflows, declared and undeclared, from the war on terror money + the expatriates money.
Will "terror money" continue?
The large current and trade deficits suggest that Pakistani ruppee cannot hold up its exchange rate and is in for a slow decline.
If the ruppee were to stay stable, then converting foreign exchange in ruppee savings and getting 10% returns in rupees makes great sense. This is what has caused a boom for the banks for the last few years.
However, a correction in ruppee exchange rate makes the rupee fixed returns a risky proposition.
In short, among stocks, bond / savings and property, what makes sense for the Pakistani expatriate inside Pakistan???
Lets start a serious discussion!!
Investor replied on Monday, January 28, 2008 03:24 PM PST
Real Estate investment is best and least risky. KSE is already close to record highs. In the coming years, there will be shortage of inhabitable land available in cities. As the overseas Pakistanis keep sending billions of dollars to their loved ones with not many viable investment options. Most of this $ will end up in real estate. This is the major reason behind stable to improving real estate prices despite the worst kind of crisis that we have seen in past 12 months.
Over the decades real estate investment in Pakistan has been the winner time and again. Only loosers in real estate are short-sighted gamblers. The smart and longterm investors will always earn best profits in real estate.
Real estate prices have been so much depressed that in general there is absolutely no more room to go further down. If there was any room prices would have gone down. The stable prices is a sign that the bottom has been reached. And from here there is only up side. |
Truman replied on Monday, January 28, 2008 11:30 PM PST
Hello Investor,
Its all about risk vs reward ratio and it has been a false impression that real estate is a "great" investment if done for long term. As compared to safest investment of term deposits, real estate beats the no risk CD by merely 1% or 1.5%. Thats good but not great considering the risks of fraudulent files, qabza groups, registry frauds, etc.
For example, my father bought a plot in Lahore Cantt area for 3 lacs 22 years ago and it is now worth ~58 lacs. This means an annual return of nearly 15%. The rate of return for 20 year term deposits offered by banks has been 13-14% on average.So real estate returned nearly 1% more than the safest investment. That's good but not great and many other investments in Pakistan (industrial sector) now a days can return much better. |
Observer replied on Tuesday, January 29, 2008 12:28 AM PST
Major part of the remittances is consumed in daily life expenses by the families of remitters, mostly in luxuries items like fuel, cars or augmented energy consumption in as a result of increased use of air-conditioners and heaters.
We all know that electricity sold by IPP’s is very expensive and govt. pay out huge amount of foreign exchange yearly. All car manufacturers also convert their profits in foreign exchange, where as exporters are not interested to bring their foreign earnings back home due to their experience with past govt.
Any way those six billions are the most vital in stabilizing the local economy and rupee.
As far I know violence in Pakistan is repulsing foreign investors and they are all heading to India. Technically, it’s India who turned out to be the biggest beneficiary of 9/11 attacks.
If I’m not wrong than most of US aid comes to Pakistan in terms of military hardware and not money, that’s why recently some anti state elements started propagating that Pakistan has deployed all that military hardware on its border with India! Only weapons cannot contribute in preventing rupee from sliding down.
We need an expert economist having lots of international exposure and repute to lead Pakistan on economic front.
At the moment, industry or any other sort of productive bussiness is more profitable than realestate. |
Investor replied on Tuesday, January 29, 2008 12:35 PM PST
Truman, don't compare fixed depostis with real estate. In fixed deposits your money is bound. If you need your money before maturity you don't get any return. In fact some cases you have to pay penalty. You can liquidate your real estate investment in time of need. Also it's not wise to base your calculations on one example of your father's investment.
Over a variety of periods real estate has proven to be more flexible and significantly more yielding profitable investment compared with fixed deposits where you get inferior return and that too at cost of blocking your money for a very long period of time. Moreover most Muslims (not only the most pios ones) consider it haram. Many of them do not choose that option even if the return is better which certainly is not. Real estate is far better than fixed deposits. |
Truman replied on Tuesday, January 29, 2008 09:00 PM PST
Investor,
If Real Estate is more liquid than it is also more risky investment. Ask anyone who bought property in 2005 and tell me how liquid is real etsate right now? It svery difficult to sell your real estate in periods of bust (last approximately 4-5 years). I gave you 20 years period because you said over "long term" real estate is better investment. You can form a term deposit ladder with different intervals and it will return profits at your desired intervals, not only at maturity.
As for term deposits being haram, my point was to compare real estate with a 100% safe investment to explain the risk to reward ratio and real estate doesn't beat the 100% safe investment by anymore than 1-1.5%. There are many other Halal investments in industrial sector that will ACTUALLY help our economy and our country whereas real estate is very non productive (dead) investment. Even term deposits help the country more (by allowing banks to lend against the money) than real estate. So if you want to benefit your country, go setup a small factory, a mill, a software house, etc. Sitting on your ass and waiting for profits is not very productive and not very halal to me. |
Investor replied on Wednesday, January 30, 2008 08:03 AM PST
Again, you are picking and choosing your 'favourite' time and time-frame to support your arguments. It's hard to engage in a serious debate with you. I don't care when and where your father invested. And 2005 is not end of the real estate world. People have not stopped making homes after 2005.
Everyone here knows early 2005 investors have taken losses due to speculative madness, greed and lack of knowledge. And, Even for buyers of this period your statement about liquidity is not valid. Yes, anyone who invested in the bubble and remained clinged to their bad investments, is in loss but it's unfair to base your argument on just one extremely worse example. Ask anyone who invested before 2004/2005 they have earned far better returns than bank deposits.
Ask people who bought cheap land in Murabbas/Acres. Did whatever else they were doing in their profession, and a time came when they sold that land in kanals and marlas. They have not become billionaires by returns on their fixed bank deposits. No one has had any betterment in their living standard due to fixed bank deposits. Only the banks have become richer. On the other hand you can see every tom, dick and harry has become rich due to this so called 'dead' investment made by them or their parents a few years to few decades back. If not for you, you should do it for your children.
No one is asking you to sit on your ass and wait for profit. Do the best in your profession, whatever it is. If you do good, hopefully you will have some savings. Invest your savings in best investment options, of which real estate is the best and time-tested one.
BTW, I feel you are convinced that your arguments re. bank deposits do not stand, and that's why you have now brought in 'other halal investments', which is good. But, I would be delighted to hear some good, safe, more yielding and viable 'other halal options' which are feasible for most readers of this site.
For example what do you suggest to a pharmacist working in Canada or a cab driver in New York, or an engineer working in Saudi Arabia? (Please don't ask them all to come back and make factories here.) |
|
| 8141) | |
| Khan |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Thursday, November 29, 2007 08:55 AM PST Reply: 
There is a lot of money in Pakistan. Upper middle class in Pakistan has better living standard than upper middle class in Europe and North America. Certainly better than most Pakistanis living abroad. If you doubt just look how expensive are cars here, how many cars owned by each family. How many BMWs you see in posh areas of Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad, Faisalabad, Gujranwala etc. And how many servants, maids, drivers etc. each household has at their disposal. You dont see that easy living in Europe and North America.
Anyone who come to this site has some property already or has interest in buying property. Only the potential buyers bash real estate so they can save some money on buying. They are acting like vulture or parasites. Bashing real estate investment for their small personal savings.
|
|
 Wednesday, November 28, 2007 06:53 PM PST Reply: 
It is strongly recommended you complete your purchases in DHA asap.
If friends remember in past few months I requested them many times to hold investments in DHA if they could do hold till Nov 15 2007 to safe on down side . ( If they had to buy or wanted to buy If they were traveling to Pakistan it was ok to buy at your visit to Pakistan).
I strongly believe worst is behind us and its time for a good slow solid recovery after 2.75 years of fall in prices that started in Mar 2005.
If you are seller holding your sales till Feb will give you more gains. If you are buyer you should immediately complete your purchases and have property transfered to your name right away to be safe. Looking to save few thousands here and there could cost you few lacs more in matter of weeks.
Ch Mujahid Yasin ( CMY )
0300-400 9967
0322-400 9967
Chaudhry Mateen replied on Wednesday, November 28, 2007 09:15 PM PST
My prediction is that after this political mess settles down, there will be a little temporary surge in the prices. You may expect 5% increase. It will not be sustainable.
Smart people will sell their plots at higher rates at that time and then after a month or two, the prices will drop again. The same people who sold their plots at higher rates will buy some of the plots again.
This is the same pattern which we have seen so far.
So, please do not get into this hype of surging prices after the political dust settles down. Make your move carefully. People are out there just to grab your hard earned money.
Good luck to all of you. |
Realestateman replied on Wednesday, November 28, 2007 09:25 PM PST
Dear Mr. Mateen
Mr. CMY has given his reasons why he has said what he has.
i would very much appreciate yr letting us know yr reasons for saying what you do.
Thanks. |
ashraf replied on Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:18 PM PST
I strongly agrees with CMY, their will be increase in the prices after general elections 2008 because 1)despite the fact that past situation was very bad still their was no drop in the prices of RE from Sept to Nov , which is a healthy sign.2)After elections lot of funds will move into Pakistani Market from abroad 3) People will become more confident to invest in RE of Pakistan.4) Very good new projects will be launched by DHA Lahore.5)Handing over of phase 6 DHA ,Lahore will start in 2008.
sofar things look very good Inshalla. |
raja amir replied on Wednesday, November 28, 2007 10:38 PM PST
is it just dha or you are talking about overall property ???? |
Chaudhry Mateen replied on Wednesday, November 28, 2007 11:28 PM PST
Dear Realestateman
CMY did NOT give any reason "why he has said what he has".
If you think that we gonna see the pre March 2005 market, then you are absolutely wrong. The prices are already very high and in most cases there is no room to increase in next 3-5 years.
Even when everything was fine in Pakistan, from March 2005 - March 2007, the prices were not increasing, because they were saturated. Can you explain why the prices did not increase during that time frame???
We gonna see the next real estate boom in approx. 10-15 years from now.
Just my two paisas. |
Ifti replied on Thursday, November 29, 2007 12:03 AM PST
I think what happened in 2005 will not repeat in the near future. But my opinion is, if the Nawaz come on Power, a lot will change in favor to Pakistan and will stabilize the Pak economy and the real estate consequently. |
Guest** replied on Thursday, November 29, 2007 01:59 AM PST
Sir, If you follow the worldwide market like in Europe and USA , the realestate prices and sales are still going down.The world is a globle village now.The prices were sky-rocketing worldwide in 2005 and the same was in Pakistan.Now housing market boom is over and trend is downward,so it will effect us too. There might be little fluctuation depending on Pakistan's own circumstances (Elections or Political instablity),but will not change much for 3 to 5 years. It is time to buy for a long term investment.Not good for short term investment.Not even Dha for any quick gains. |
Moderator (NY) replied on Thursday, November 29, 2007 06:07 AM PST
> but no one on this forum wants to hear what I said. In fact, a few times my posts were deleted
> (the posts had no derogatory language in it, but were deleted because I said the same thing that
> you have).
We do not delete posts just because it advocates a trend, regardless whether upwards or downwards.
Most of posts get deleted for reasons like irrelevance, derogatory language, personal accusations, anti-state remarks, fraudulent impersonation or dealers without full identity.
If you believe your post(s) have been deleted without justified cause, you can forward that at lahorerealestate@gmail.com |
Shahid Khan replied on Thursday, November 29, 2007 07:32 AM PST
"We gonna see the next real estate boom in approx. 10-15 years from now"
Chaudhry Mateen from your comments above I can clearly see you are totally lost. I don't understand why people like you visit this property web site when they hate any roperty investments in Pakistan. Only goal of people like you is to discourage others from making new investments in Pakistani property so you could buy property for you at lower price. Guys like you hurt thousands of overseas Pakistanis and poor people in Pakistan to save a few thousands for yourself. Shame on you. |
Khan replied on Thursday, November 29, 2007 08:27 AM PST
There is a lot of money in Pakistan. Upper middle class in Pakistan has better living standard than upper middle class in Europe and North America. Certainly better than most Pakistanis living abroad. If you doubt just look how expensive are cars here, how many cars owned by each family. How many BMWs you see in posh areas of Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad, Faisalabad, Gujranwala etc. And how many servants, maids, drivers etc. each household has at their disposal. You dont see that easy living in Europe and North America.
Anyone who come to this site has some property already or has interest in buying property. Only the potential buyers bash real estate so they can save some money on buying. They are acting like vulture or parasites. Bashing real estate investment for their small personal savings. |
CMY replied on Thursday, November 29, 2007 09:26 AM PST
First I would like to let visitors know Chaudhry Mateen and Mohsin was one person ( Or two person in same room posting from same computer from NY USA ). I had deleted post of Mohsin praising Chpudry Mateen from same room :).
Ch Mateen sahib I dont understand why you had to use Mohsin nick to praiseyour sely. I would have lot of respect for you if you had used Ch Mateen to make further points. First making a sense able post and than praising yourself with difrent name is not a good practice. Why grown up people do this? If a teen ager does it may be ok but educated grown up person should not do this.
If you have time go back and read my posts from Mar to July this year and you will understand why prices will rise from here. I am busy in office so I will make it short to explain few reasons here.
1 In last 8 months since Mar 2008 with CJ sacking 1000s of investors that wanted to make new investments in property held their purchases to get political situation more clear. Now political situation is very clear. You have Musharaf as president and you will have Nawaz or Benazir as prime minster.
You will get possession in DHA 6 in comoing weeks.
You will see major new projects launche in DHA Lahore Karachi and Islamabad in comoing weeks. These big developers do a lot of research to see new investors mood before the launch of these Mega projects.
In coming weeks you will see Broadway opened in middle of DHA 8 that will bypass DHA traffic from Batta Chaok.
Eid is coming and After that Pakistanis from US will be visiting Pakistan immediately after new year. Most of people in US drive taxi to make good money. Their season end after New years and Taxi business slowdown for them to halt from Jan to Mar so they prefer to spend that time in Pakistan and when come here they do lot of buying . Thats the main reason Jan is always very good for property market in Lahore.
Foreign investors will return to Pakistan after more stability is seen on political front. Elections is a drama and dont expect too much trouble on elections.
I have many other reasons but now I have to go to DHA for a plot transfer. |
Farhan Malik replied on Saturday, December 1, 2007 06:31 PM PST
I feel things are getting better and back on track. Mr. CMY is right and logical in advising investors for investment. Ground lost by the property is likely to be regained before elections and steady rise is likely to follow. |
|
|
 Friday, October 26, 2007 09:11 AM PST Reply: 
Malik Riaz Hussain (CEO Bahria Town) is appearing on GEO TV today Dear All,
Salaam,
GEO TV is presenting Malik Riaz Hussain interview in its program EIK DIN GEO KAY SATH tonight at about 10 PM.
He is supposed to discuss his future plans and his working strategy etc.
Thanks.
Raheela replied on Friday, October 26, 2007 12:28 PM PST
Kaisrani Sahib! You seem to be very well wisher of Malik Riaz Sahib. Could you ask him what he did with small and poor investors Phase-9 Rawalpindi plot holders? I believe you will never do so. Shame on the part of those people who recommend Malik Sahib on this website. |
TRUTH! replied on Friday, October 26, 2007 02:38 PM PST
KEEP IT UP RAHEELA!
I REALLY APPRECIATED YOUR COMMENTS ON MR. MALIK |
Tahir Khan replied on Friday, October 26, 2007 05:23 PM PST
hi RAHEELA
most of the people bought files in bt ph9 beyond their budget and got stuck after they could not submit installments. bt ph8 is being developed at very good development standards and ph9 will be a masterpiece. mind it I said "will be"
Mr Hussain Qaiserani is the most respected and undisputed person among us. he has always been here to guide without any interests.he is neither a property dealer nor has any affiliations with bt. I feel sorry for you poor lady. you should be very careful for criticizing a person of this stature. please learn to accept the responsibility of your wrong decisions. do you know what is a real estate investment. all this bull shit in Pakistan is gambling not an investment.
you MUST excuse from mr Qaiserani. |
ALi replied on Friday, October 26, 2007 07:42 PM PST
Malik riaz just slipped his tongue in the interview. he said clearly that " ham wo daku hain jo ameeron ka maal loot ker gareebon mein bantay hain"
he used gareebon first by mistake which is true and then he changed it to ameeron ka maal.
Shame on YOU |
Ali replied on Friday, October 26, 2007 09:23 PM PST
Another Victim
please ask Malik Riaz where are lower blocks of Sec C and where is ph 9.A shameless idiot,luteera.I have deposited all 10 instalments of Sec c block Janiper?where is my plot,nowhere.Even work has not started.Anyone who wants to yet support Malik ,well??? |
Hussain Kaisrani replied on Friday, October 26, 2007 09:29 PM PST
Raheela Sahib/Sahiba! I am very much well wisher of visitors of this site. I have only reproduced information without any comments. I am sorry if my post has hurt your feeling. Lets see what he says in his interview.
Tahir Khan! Many Thanks for your kind words. I am always ready to receive any kind of response. |
Abdul replied on Friday, October 26, 2007 09:58 PM PST
Dear Ali Bhai
I feel sorry if I have hurt your feeling , I am not supporting Malik Riaz but let me tell you BT is much better society then the E-16 & D-18 you are supporting for.
Since you have experience of hurt you should not support E-16, D-18 ect. |
ALi replied on Saturday, October 27, 2007 12:19 AM PST
Stop comparing societies. Everyone got eyes and brain and their own budget. are you going to give them money from your pocket?
you cannot compare 50 lac with 15 lac. let people decide, dont insult them. |
Khan replied on Saturday, October 27, 2007 09:24 AM PST
I deposited the requisite amount to convert my Phase 9 file into Phase 8 Rawalpindi, however, the balloting which was supposed to happen in August 2007 is still not in sight. When you ask Bahria office, they have a standard response "Soon". Infact, I think they themselves are not aware of any development in this regard and this conversion was another ploy in Bahria's cap to fool people. |
Muhammad Amjad replied on Saturday, October 27, 2007 12:04 PM PST
Are BT and RP housing schemes are the same direction? |
Reality replied on Sunday, October 28, 2007 12:43 PM PST
Malik Riaz is the biggest fraudia after Benazir and Asif Zardari. He is sucking the blood of poor Pakistanis and politicians are involved in it. |
|
|
 Friday, September 14, 2007 11:45 AM PST Reply: 
Gold reached highest value (since last one year) USD 711 per Oz
Gold reached highest value (since last one year) USD 711 per Oz
Good opportunity for investment for small investors
Allah Hafiz
Kailani replied on Friday, September 14, 2007 02:43 PM PST
Yes
Gold has reached highest price and so is euro. In fact it is the USD who is sinking. I pridict that it will crash soon. So I advise all friends to convert any USD or USD dollar related assets (such as Saudi Riyals etc) to gold or other metals. Or Euro etc. Is it a wonder that Bill Gate the richest man of the world has 30% of the world silver and he also purchased lot of Euros?
Or you can choose real estate. However real estate investment need a solid strategy. No files. No undeveloped lands etc
Hope that friends will benefit from this small advice.
Thanks |
saeedusa replied on Friday, September 14, 2007 06:21 PM PST
kailani;
Weaker dollar is attracting more money to usa and usa is exporting more stuff to europe because it's cheap that's why cisco had a good earning because their routers are cheaper.Friend of mine has high tech company in europe and he was saying that he is buying so much stuff from usa because it's cheap.With one euro they get almost 1.5 dollar so more money will be comimg to usa in the future. |
@ i Shaikh replied on Saturday, September 15, 2007 01:12 PM PST
Gold Price high.... WHT SENCE FOR INVESTMENT ??????
LOL
:))))
My friend its artificial Price and it will come down very soon....
thanx |
ua replied on Monday, September 17, 2007 02:13 PM PST
If the price for anything has reached a record high, it is usually bad time to invest in it... |
|
|
 Thursday, August 16, 2007 03:01 PM PST Reply: 
I am very glad that Br. Jamshaid has been saved from a 'great loss' by Br. Salman A Khan’s undisclosed reasons of massacre of files and immunity of plots (if ph 7 has plots at all). He sure has supreme convincing power. And I respect him for his contributions here.
I admit the defeat of my faulty logic, and will not drag this further (i.e. will avoid further posts on this topic), despite the fact that I feel convinced about the following points:
1. I see DHA Ph 7 'plot' as a HIGH RISK, LOW REWARD file (a DHA promise to deliver a plot in future) WITH a map, and a plot number pointing to a location on that map.
2. Practically, your plot is something you can stand on and have possession of, to make home.
3. A DHA ph 7 plot is nothing more than a relatively matured but more expensive file in the worst-located phase in entire DHA Master Plan (VERY SORRY if anyone feels bad by these words, but the facts cannot be changed, and the locations cannot be moved.)
4. I feel (may be, I am wrong in thinking that) that Mr. Salman A. Khan for some reason seems unfairly biased towards ph 7. (He seldom shares any fact or insider info which may prove negative about ph 7, although it is hard to believe that he only hears positive news about ph 7 from his insider sources, and only bad news about files). If that is the case, I humbly request Mr. Salman A. Khan sahib to be more fair, and not look at things through certain preset colored glasses, for the sake of fairness. NOT EVERY THING IS GREEN ABOUT PH 7, AND NOT EVERYTHING IS RED ABOUT FILES.
5. I also feel (again, I may be wrong) that he found it hard to counter-argue my couple of posts (9/10 Vs ph 7), in a constructive sense, and the best he came up with was the scare-tactic about the files. And reality is nothing more than that. The reason I feel so is he only recently admitted owning a ph 8 file. May be he has sold it now. But if he still owns it, it is unfair to tell others files are bad. I also don’t think that there is any drastically bad news that he can share. Otherwise he would send that to emails of people requesting it, to let them assess. If he sends anything to those emails, the recipients are requested to share the core here at least briefly, in a presentable way, to communicate the basic concern.
6. It’s a fact that Mr. Salman A Khan, never favoured files much, but before he had different reasons for that. I myself value his arguments greatly BUT based on my research about the “Individual Worths of DHA Phases”, I feel DHA files at current prices are no-doubt extremely good, LOW RISK, HIGH REWARD LONG-TERM investments compared with plots (or so called plots of ph 7). Ph 8 files are very good investment, but 9/10 files are better due to very low risk of loss involved in worst case, and excellent percentage wise reward in best case. Reasons are discussed in great detail in the two previous posts.
7. Anyway it’s up to the people to decide. We are human beings and can be wrong. But there is nothing wrong with trying to know more, and sharing what we know.
Salman A. Khan replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 03:50 PM PST
Dear Dha ph 9/10 vs ph 7 sahib,
For some reason you sound extremely angry at me! Is it because of the respect and trust the viewers have shown for me?
Your conjecture regarding my motives stems more from the perception that most of the viewers seem to favour my judgement over yours than anything else. (Although your piece of work has been highly researched and contains a very high level of technical jargon and can perhaps even be called a piece of art!)
The question remains was your motive as high minded as your logic and words ? Because my dear friend, sincerety has its own vocabulary and doesnt need much research!
As you very rightly concluded: let people be the judge and decide for themselves . Believe me my good friend ..people are no fool!
Regards, |
Atiq Rehman replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 04:29 PM PST
Dear All ,
Assalam Alaikum ,
Reading through the various posts on one should or should not buy files ,discussion aside i am impressed with the level of English Language used by both my brothers specially Salman Sahib .Keep up the good work gentlemen of making this forum more useful and enjoyable to visit .
Wasalam ,
Atiq |
DHA PH 9/10 VS PH 7 replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 04:56 PM PST
Dear Salman A. Khan Sahib,
1. Let Allah alone be the judge of motives. Let’s leave that there.
2. There is a difference between being “Biased” towards something, and being “Convinced” of something. My analysis and conclusions may be wrong, but my motives are not.
3. I do not doubt your motives. I do not believe that you have any intention to misguide people. But, HALF-TRUTHS can also be dodgy at times. It is your moral duty to share bad news along with the good news too, regardless of your holding or likeness. Your analysis has always been mostly limited to DHA ph 7, and you only pick +ve news about DHA ph 7 to share with others, which I think is unfair. But I don’t think it amounts to bad intentions of misguiding others. In my opinion, your posts can be much more useful for readers if you look outside of dha 7 and do fair comparisons of possible risks and rewards of investment at least in other phases of DHA, and preferably outside of DHA. We are discussing real estate investment here. Let’s take an example (if you allow me), at 70+ age (May Allah give you longer and healthier life), you probably do not want to make homes on your ph 5, ph 7 plots and ph 8 file. Do you? That holding is for investment purpose perhaps to pass on as gift to your children. You may have your owns reasons but in my opinion your own investment portfolio like holding a saturated already very high priced (1 Crore, more or less) ph 5 plot may not be very rewarding to hold for investment purpose. That is a ripe fruit now. If I were you, I would sell that to someone who wants to make home and can afford the price. And I will invest somewhere else where there will be more room to grow. Now others may disagree with you or me about what is best investment. You may be right or you may be wrong in your conclusions. But let’s not start doubting each other’s motives.
4. Your repute here is more due to your insider sources. Not everyone follows your posts word by word. They can hear insider info from you which they normally do not hear from others. Many people do not have insider info. Some who do are bound by their own limitations. I do not believe much in insider info. Insider considerations and decisions can change at any time, and it’s not prudent to rely on insider info alone. I rely more on the current ground realities and probabilities of future price movements based on un-qualified and non-tainted research. Insider info alone, is a medicine that can at times prove to be deadly.
5. I am not at all angry at you. Why should I be? We are not fighting for a medal here. I respect you and your views. At the same time I disagree with ‘some’ of your analysis and conclusions. It is very possible to disagree with respect. I say “may be you are right, but this is how I feel. I agree with this and disagree with that”. And I certainly do not care if someone follows my advice or yours. It is up to them. I wish all Good Luck with their investment. I feel if I have conveyed what I have learned, that is job well done for me. At least it gives a certain perspective about how they should go for ANY real estate investment. I think a lot of people now know a lot more about ph 9/10 and ph 7 than they knew before. Some may agree, and some may disagree with contents. And that’s fine.
Regards
OVER AND ALL |
Salman A. Khan replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 05:43 PM PST
Dear Phase9/10 versus phase7 sahib,
One question..are you CMY's younger brother Naveed Yaseen and if so why are you concealing your identity? |
Mentor replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 05:56 PM PST
@dha ph 9/10 vs ph 7
I for one really appreciate your analysis. Debates here pave the way for informed decision making for the readers of this board. Like most here i am not privy to "Insider" information and will base my investments on my own research and best judgement and as far as my best judgement is concerned phase 9/10 vs phase 7 is a no brainer. Phase 9/10 seems the best investment in dha at the moment. The reasons have already been explained in your post and i whole heartedly 2nd them. However IMHO and I may miss the target by a country mile,investing in real estate will not beat inflation for many (atleast 4) years or so. Worldwide housing markets are either cold or in a state of recession. If we dissect the rise and fall of the real estate market in Pakistan, the pattern we get parallels the international trends.
In short as far as my myopic vision goes,be it phase 9/10 or phase 7,now is not the time to invest in real estate unless that investment is meant for the very long term(10yrs). |
Khan replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 12:55 AM PST
It is fair to say that if Mr or Ms DHA PH 9/10 VS PH 7 has good intention for the peoples of Pakistan then reveal your name and let people be judge of, who is right and wrong. |
Naveed Yaseen replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 02:55 AM PST
Salman sahib its not me. |
A friend replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 06:24 AM PST
Salman sahib please check your E-mail |
DHA PH 9/10 VS PH 7 replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 11:11 AM PST
1. If the name comforts you more than logic, then you can call me Khalid Mehmood, or whatever you like. (If you need more than that, then I will do it when the requirement is applied to everybody)
2. If you prefer the message, GET IT.
3. If you don't like the message, don't like it.
4. If you think I am wrong, CONVINCE ME otherwise.
5. If you are convinced I am right. Still do more research and seek others' opinion.
6. Should you be skeptical? Yes
7. Should you be rational? Yes |
Ali replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 12:03 PM PST
Dear DHA Ph 9/10 vs ph 7
You are a man with very clear thinking. I agree with your analysis and thats what matters. God bless you. |
Salman A. Khan replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 12:52 PM PST
Dear Naveed Yaseen sahib,
Thank you for your reply.I am sorry for thinking it might be you. Your reply has put my mind at ease.I know that we have had differences in the past but all through our association and inspite of our differences of opinion ,I have really admired the sincere effort and hard work put in by MR CMY, Mr. Abid and yourself in initiating and keeping this forum alive.
In a country like Pakistan ,where one is liable to be attacked on the personal level and accused of ulterior motives the minute one opens one's mouth, running such an open forum requires super human patience, forbearance and loads of stamina.
Commentators like myself can share a post or two, once or twice a month and go back to our lives, but for you all it is a daily, hourly, minute to minute commitment and in a field like real estate you are liable to be bitterly criticised and hit below the belt by those who feel their investments threatened by any comment or advice no matter how well intentioned your advice may be!
My you all have the strength and perseverance to continue this grand pioneer effort!
Sincerely |
Stasigr replied on Tuesday, October 30, 2007 02:32 AM PST
Hello, very nice site, keep up good job!
Admin good, very good. |
|
|
 Tuesday, August 14, 2007 08:18 PM PST Reply: 
RE: POST # 33456
Development charges are just one factor. Don’t get carried away with that. Read point # 7 again. The development charges are factored in there. You have mentioned 12 lacs. Even with 15 lacs development charges ph 9/10 will give significantly better returns than ph 7 plot IN THE LONG RUN. You cannot factor in FUTURE dev. charges TODAY.
1. Development charges will be applicable after ph 9/10 ballot. There is at least 4 to 5 years gap between development charges imposition of ph 7 and ph 9/10.
2. The longer this time gap the greater the difference in development charges, but at the same time lesser the average investment involved over a period of time. Dev. charges money will remain stuck in ph 7 plot 4 to 5 years more than ph 9/10, and in the long run due to fundamental advantages of ph 9/10 over ph 7 discussed above, ph 9/10 will prove to be much better return on average investment involved over that time-period as explained in point 7.
3. Again, the thing to understand here is: the longer the time-span between ph 7 and 9/10 dev charges imposition the smaller the average investment involved (favours 9/10). And the other scenario, the shorter the time-span between ph 7 and 9/10 dev charges imposition, the smaller the amount of 9/10 dev charges (ironically, again favours 9/10 due to quicker delivery of plots and lower amount of charges).
4. Another important thing to understand here is 9/10 will automatically become more and more attractive buy as plots in other phases improve in price as described in point # 6 of the referred post. Suppose you buy phase 7 plot today and in 2 years its price increase by 20%. Ph 9/10 being smaller amount and relatively low risk involved will increase at better acceleration or percentage. The amount of increase in lacs may be less than ph 7 but percentage of increase will be much more than ph 7. The longer the term, the better the returns for ph 9/10 compared with ph 7. As explained in prev post, against a hundred percent increase in DHA 7 price over 5 to 7 years, 9/10 investment at 17 lacs today will yield more than two hundred percent return on average investment involved during this 5 to 7 years time-span after deducting very high amount of development charge, assuming all dev charges paid by then and also assuming 9/10 will still be well behind ph 7 by 15 lacs. These assumptions are very conservative and reflect worst case scenerios over long-term comparions of ph 7 and 9/10 giving all benefit of doubt to ph 7.
5. Basically what I am trying to convey to plot-lovers is: the more plot prices grow in any of DHA phases there will be better and automatic percentage wise return over average investment involved in ph 9/10 over that same period of time. We are not discussing months here. This analysis is only applicable for medium to long term investment. Over very small period of time (few months to a year), it is possible but very unlikely that ph 7 plot will give better percentage wise return than ph 9/10. But the longer the period the better the %age returns in ph 9/10 compared with ph 7. THE TIME FACTOR and RETURN ON AVERAGE INVESTMENT INVOLVED are the key-words here.
BOTTOM LINE: Ph 7 Plot may win the SPRINT, but 9/10 will win the MARATHON. The analysis is not for SPRINT. It’s for MARATHON. (BTW, it is very likely 9/10 will win the SPRINT too but MARATHON is almost certain.)
P.S. 1: History of real estate investment tells us that best returns are made on well-researched LONG-TERM investments in cheap/underpriced instruments (e.g. raw land, DHA files, etc. – btw, DHA files are more secure than non-DHA plots due to Qabza and Fraud risks in non-DHA plots); and NOT IN poorly researched/SHORT-TERM investments in already saturated market of developed or soon to be developed PLOTS. Developed plots have already gained well and are meant to make homes with less room of further gains. But that is a whole different chapter. This analysis is for LONG TERM investment purpose only. It’s better to make good well-research long-term investment and then sleep over it not worrying about market volatility. OR you an exhaust yourself with short-term trading and get screwed by market volatility and overhead cost of frequent buy/sells. Choice is yours.
P.S. 2: Everybody has the right to disagree. BUT keep in mind, I am convinced about the above analysis and in previous post, based on my thorough research. If you believe otherwise based on your research CONVINCE ME OTHERWISE using logic, facts and figures. I would appreciate serious experts' detailed views ONLY, and will ignore any superficial statements, and all comments from non-serious people. The purpose of this website is to learn from each other by initiating and participating in useful discussions.
Salman A. Khan replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 09:27 PM PST
Dear Viewers,
Beware of files! I have heard wise people project and praise Dha lahore phase 8 on this site for a very long time (suddenly they have all quietened down now) and even today its balloting is still nowhere in sight.I am on record of advising people to stay clear of phase 8 files.(when the pandora box finally opens (concerning phase 8)there will be a lot of innocent casualities.
In the case of Dha lahore phase 9/10 files...mark my words its going to be a complete massacre. I am not at liberty to say more since the moderators of this site have bound my hands and advised me to be careful of my words otherwise my posts will be deleted so all I can say is please stay clear of files..Go to some other society if you dont like Dha plots but please buy regular plots after full scrutiny.
p.s. I have lots of concrete information in support of what I have said but I am not at liberty to relate it on this site because my post will be deleted!
Sincerely |
Usman replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 09:39 PM PST
Salman A. Khan sahib thanks for the post regarding DHA-8,9/10. Understand that you are not at liberty to give more detail on this website.
Could you send me that info on my e-mail at 'Usman_Lodhi2000@yahoo.com' as couple of my family members also hold DHA-8 and Parkview (DHA-8 Ext) files. Your info may help us better making some key decisions. Thanks, |
DHA PH 9/10 VS PH 7 replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 10:24 PM PST
Dear Salman A. Khan Sahib,
Please do not scare us. Let's assume there will be massacre in phase 8 and 9/10 files, what is your assumption about ph 5, 6 and 7 plots. From investor’s point of view, is it wise to think that plots in ph 5 to 7 will remain shielded somehow. It’s natural that in case of a massacre more blood/air will come out from where more blood/air is. Phase 9/10 already has kind of anemia and taking iron pills. There is not much blood in it at 17 lacs. However a massacre of 9/10 will be more horrible for ph 5 to 7. Do you disagree? Do you think massacre in 9/10 and 8 will leave ph 1 to 7 plots un-affected? I don’t think so. Let’s assume ph 9/10 will go to ZERO. I wonder what will happen to rest of DHA? Even in worst case scenario for ph 9/10 comparatively there seems more risk of loss in plots because of their inflated prices.
If you really believe there will be a massacre in any phase of DHA, your logical recommendation should be to avoid ALL DHA.
I do not agree with this doomsday scenario. |
ali replied on Wednesday, August 15, 2007 08:31 PM PST
i agree with Salman sahib its will take minimum 20 years for phase 9 10 to develop atleast look at its size it bigger than phase 678 combined and i visited phase 6 today even A B and H blacks are not complete yet i donto see phase 6 getting completley devleoped (not talking about populated) before two years time then there is phase 7 and then phase 8 still phase 5 is going through development .........so saying that developmental charges of phase 9 10 will be in tune of 12 lacs does nto make sense and more over we donot what will happen in 20 years ......so people a bird in hand is better than 2 in............... :))) |
Muhammad Jameel replied on Wednesday, August 15, 2007 10:38 PM PST
Dear salman A Khan I would aprriciate if you send the Dtail of Your information on my Email
jameelm68@yahoo.coom
Regards |
Khan replied on Wednesday, August 15, 2007 11:23 PM PST
I agreed with Salman A Khan sahib. There is a disaster waiting to happen in this market. So please be care full. Especially those who have earn hard money get out while you can.
Housing market was led by USA through out the world and now USA is leading this market down.
regards |
Shahid Rasul replied on Wednesday, August 15, 2007 11:37 PM PST
Salman Sahib, If you could please include me in the email list whom you could send information about DHA 8,9,10 I will appreciate that.
Shahid_Rasul@Yahoo.com |
saad replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 12:04 AM PST
salman sahib plz send your details about the dha plots and files to me also on this mailing address.saadrizwan95@gmail.com. i think they are not going to remove your mails this time.It just would make them suspicious.bye. |
arif replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 02:04 AM PST
salman a khan sahib please send the same info to me on my email
marifalvi@yahoo.ca and oblidge |
saeedusa replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 02:19 AM PST
Please include me too saeedusa@gmail.com |
shahid replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 02:22 AM PST
Dear salman sb, please email the secret stuff to this email aslo:
ziamail@gmail.com |
Ahmed replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 03:32 AM PST
what a panic created by mr SALMAN my advise to him is instead of sending so many emails why he cant just announce THE THING on this site so a huge number of investor can survive form this havoc. dear SALMAN shaib i assure you no one will do any thing to your post because this is why this site known for only for the benefit of the people and i am sure mr CMY will also be very keen to heard about this BREAKING news. and dear mr ali you should check mr CMY ,s post where he showed the actual size of the ph 9 .10 you must be surprised to see the real size and please bring some facts not allusions it will be great help thanks . and people please dont get panic use your head even if :something: happen to files dramatically do you think that the plots will remain save and sound. i was involved in property business 10 year back i got max. from files rather than plots. |
Zain replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 04:27 AM PST
Salman Sb should be given liberty to share their views on the forum as a lot of people have requested that information and I believe its better to have it posted rather then sent to every one by email so the people who don't believe the report can also share their comments and defend it. |
Mughal replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 06:37 AM PST
Dear Salman A Khan,
You are right, I am reading your post for some time, all of them are based on facts and figures as it supposes to be.
Every one has to die one day regardless of money he has, my appeal to you please open a forum and write all the facts you know of the files business specially DHA. I sold my DHA files and plot just because its not a public welfare but is a Gen welfare society.
I have long saying people not to invest in files business but to invest in a plot those which are develop but buy only if the price is based on facts.
Request to CMY please do not delete any post which is for the welfare of peoples. I have seen if some one writes truth you either ban him or delete his post, in this case you can not claim that this is an open forum?!
of course CMY you are making money by giving info to people and attracting them too, you are working with this tool to the best like western doing.
when we will die we will be asked what you did when you know that people was endangered. Allah almighty will say! “I gave you wisdom did you use it for right purpose OR use it for your personal benefits only. “can your money save you now from hell fire?” at that time what answer we will have.
When Allah gives us “Money, wisdom and Power” we must use it rightly not for our use only but for people’s welfare that is what Islam says.
My Request to all people please stay away from files business no matter which society it belongs to and do not buy any property which is more then 25 lacs any where in Lahore. |
abc replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 08:06 AM PST
include lahoriinusa@gmail.com |
JAV replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 08:28 AM PST
please can u send me the information as well...my emial address is jahmed16@hotmail.com |
From UAE replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 09:10 AM PST
Whoever has done this analysis, has definitly impressed many people with his marketing skills, rational-based arguments, research, and overall knowledge about DHA in general and Ph 9 in particular.
Dear, I would like to have your contact details if you are in the business of realestate in Pakistan - I always prefer dealing with the sound professionals. Can you please post your email address on this forum? and I will contact you soon. Thanks. From UAE. |
ali replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 10:42 AM PST
@mr ahemd
sir my assessment of size of phase 9 10 is based on the map provided by respected cmy sahib............ and if u have visited phase 6 in person u can see it for your self whats the development status ............ i have no idea about dooms day in dha 9 10 but i dislike phase 9 10 only becuase of the fact that it will take years for any thing to come on ground dreaming about some thin and practically putting it on ground are 2 different things.....even at hight of army rule DHA struggled to get hold of one village near L block and hence main blvd of phase 6 is still in complete.........u can see it ur self......... still u canot build house properly in A and B blocks properly.....only made shift arrangements no water tanks......... where as dha says we will do this and that in one year......... i am not opposed to dha its the best housing scheme but for phase 9 10 the time line for any thing solid to come on ground is too long.......... |
Salman A. Khan replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 11:42 AM PST
Dear Ahmed sahib,Mr..Dha phase9/10 vs phase7 sahib and Viewers,
I have no intention of trying to create fear or panic..or create ill will or foster controversy etc. Infact I have brought down my contribution/posts to this web site to the very minimum.
I hardly ever post anything now and I cant understand that when I do finally try to convey some well intentioned advice it is construed as an controversial attempt. How can anyone ,let alone an ordinary individual like myself influence the market or the investors in their choices of investment?
But even a layman knows the difference between a plot and a file by now! There are so many unknown areas in files..namely no officially designated area.(no map), no accurate number of files..(different people's claims of knowing and relating the factual number of files is all conjecture).No idea of the actual of development charges.etc.
Even if my post is totally ignored ,I think by now people know the lies spread around the phase 8 balloting.I am on record for saying phase 8 will not be balloted till phases 6/7 are developed.Lots of phase 8 files will end up across Barki road.
Believe me when I say phases 9 and 10 will be balloted as different phases with different areas otherwise dha would have named it just phase 9. Why would they call it Phase 9/10?
I am not going to give any specific proof on this site because of obvious reasons.In any case people are by now wise enough to decide on their own.Although I consider it my moral duty to share what little I can and try to prevent loss to other investors.Dontwe all remember what happened to phase 7 file prices after it was balloted.?
In any case I am quite an insignificant person..please treat me as such and make your own well researched decisions.
sincerely, |
Jamshaid replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 12:44 PM PST
Janab Khan Sahib! As regards to your moral duty to prevent loss to other investors by commenting on post of Mr....DHA Phase 9/10 Vs Phase-7, I feel personnaly myself that you have saved me of a great loss. After reading post of Mr.....Dha Phase 9/10, I decided to sell immediately one of my plots located in a good society and to buy 2 files of Phase 9/10 for investment purpose,but now I have dropped my idea after reading your useful advice. It is good or bad in future but I am satisfied with your advice. I may add here that viewers of this forum trust you and love you. God bless u. |
Salman A. Khan replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 02:06 PM PST
Dear Jamshaid sahib,
Thank you so much for your extremely kind and generous words and sentiments but please remember I am a very ordinary humble person with countless faults ! Please just pray for my forgiveness!
One important fact that I may add ( as Mr Habib has already very wisely pointed out in an earlier post related to phase 9/10)is that the price of phase 9/10 is not currently 17 lacs ..it is 17 lacs plus atleast 12 lacs(29 lacs)!(if future development charges remain the same although they may well be more! ).
It is dishonest to compare the prices of 9/10 and phase 7 and claim that phase 9/10 is 17 lacs while phase 7 (below average) plots are 31/32 lacs..The actual comparison should be 29 lacs versus 31/32 lacs! |
DHA PH 9/10 VS PH 7 replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 02:50 PM PST
Dear Salman A. Khan Shaib,
This whole main post was written to describe this 12 lacs development charges, how and when those should be factored in based on various time-frames, and return on average investment involved during that time-frame. Perhaps you overlooked the post. Or just want to ignore the facts. Please read this main post again thoroughly and not just over-look. |
worldguy replied on Thursday, August 16, 2007 06:45 PM PST
Dear Salman A Khan & other respected members
@Salman A Khan I don't think so any one should have to get upset from your post as long as I know you are doing good job well-done.
I wonder if you or any other member could give me some advice I want to buy one knaal plot in DHA having in mind to make home in 4 to 5 years my budget is 40 to 45lakh please advice me in which phase/Block should I buy I know in Pakistan people have allot & allot money but believe me it's life time effort to buy just one plot so please give me your best advice may God keep you guys in safe hand & happy (Ameen) |
Shakeel Ahmad replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 01:39 AM PST
Mughal saab why you bought SL files if you dislike all files. These SL files are now plots and you don't like files anymore? Give us a break from this BS. You want us to buy your crap SL plots with under 25 lacs budget. Very funny.
Mughal replied on Wednesday, June 27, 2007 02:09 PM PST
Dear "A state life victim”
Look at my previous posts, I am an overseas investor, have some property in Islamabad and part of it in Lahore; I bought State life many files just because of Location and price. It is fact too that Malik mubark has the sufficient Land for his PH2.
Those are not happy with State Life are welcome to sell State Life, they can invest in DHA, Bahria or any good HS they like. |
Asad khan. replied on Friday, August 17, 2007 03:15 AM PST
Salam,
Salman A khan sahab this is fear/facter game let the people play this game.Here i saw every body wana take risk so why we are scearing them.I know one thing you are saying absolutly right.
Let the cow go into the water.
Time will deside who is right who is rong.
May Allah bless all of us.
thank you |
|
|
 Monday, August 13, 2007 06:32 PM PST Reply: 
DHA phase 9/10 is much better than ph 7 for investment purpose. To explain why, here is a comparison of ph 7 and ph 9/10 (in reply to Shahjee’s question):
1. DHA ph 9/10 is safest among DHA with lowest risk of loss on investment. An investor’s first consideration should always be to prevent or limit the loss in worst case scenario.
2. The buying and selling price difference is negligible in case of files. If you buy a plot chances are you may be over-paying for a location and better deals may have been missed out for similar locations. Files on the other hand are much more liquid (easy and quick to buy and sell) at fair market rates which vary only by a few thousand across the board, at a given time.
3. There is a huge psychological advantage of ph 9/10 which is it’s easiest among whole of DHA to fit in investors budgets who have lowest DHA standard buying power. Moreover people with higher budgets can use this investment instrument to better diversify their long-term portfolios. DHA 9/10 files can also be used for hedging or limiting risk by REITs real estate investment strategists.
4. In long-term perspective, DHA ph 9/10 has exceptionally better location than DHA ph 7. It is closer to recently widened Ferozepur road, and rest of new city like DHA 1 to 4, Modle town, Liberty, Johar Town, Iqbal Town etc. On the other hand DHA ph 7 goes towards BRB canal. And this phase is worst located among all DHA phases announced so far.
5. DHA ph 9/10 will give you more percentage wise return on investment in the long term than any of DHA plots not just ph 7. For example in 5 years a DHA ph 5 plot at 1 crore will give a return of only 15 percent (at best) to go to 1 crore 15 lacs. A ph 6 plot at 65 will give a 30% return to go to 85. And ph 7 plot at 40 lacs today will give a return of 50% to go to 60 lacs. Whereas ph 9/10 file at 17 has a potential of giving 100 to 200% return by going between 35 and 50 lacs in five years.
6. If you like other phases of DHA based on your research. And think that a particular phase will go up more than other phases. For example if you like ph 7 or ph 8 and think that prices in those phases will go up. And even if you are corret, DHA 9/10 will automatically increase as a side-effect in comparison. Its very likely to happen that as the prices of plots in earlier phases rise, lower-costing ph 9/10 will become more and more attractive and will more likely fit the budget of most potential buyers wishing to invest in DHA but unable to buy high-cost plots.
7. Say you buy a plot in ph 7 at 40 lacs today thinking it will give you best returns in five years and it will go to 80 lacs in 5 to 7 years time. Or may be you bought ph 7 allocation at peak price of more than 70 lacs and now holding a plot worth 40 lacs which includes development charges. Your net cost of plot is 79 lacs and you hope that in coming 5 to 7 years you will recover your loss at some point it will go back to 80 Lacs. WHAT DO YOU THINK PRICE OF DHA PH 9/10 WILL BE AT THAT TIME WHEN PHASE 7 RECOVERS YOUR LOSS AND GOES TO EIGTHY AGAIN (Or 79 = 70+9). It would be unwise to think that Ph 9/10 will remain sitting at 17. When your DHA 7 plot will be at 80 recovering your loss, ph 9/10 will be very close behind in worst case and ahead in best case in 7 to 10 years time-frame (with better than ph 7 %age return in 4-5 year time too as you have asked about that time frame of 4-5 years). So now calculate the percentage of return from 17 Lacs. Even if DHA 9/10 is at 65 Lacs when DHA 7 plot of 40 lacs doubles to 80. The return on your initial investment of 17 lacs after excluding 10 to 12 or even 15 lacs dev charges will be more than two hundred percent. Basically you should understand that even in worst case scenarios ph 9/10s %age return will still be more than ph 7 plot, in the given time-frame of 4 to 5 years. In best case scenarios the returns of ph 9/10 will be more than double the return of a ph 7 plot.
8. The actual size of DHA ph 9/10 is less than half of ph 6/7. This is a fact which is not commonly known yet. You have to see in Satellite images that there is very small area left after State Life ph 1 & 2, Formanites ph 1 & 2 and other societies like Anmol, GTS etc.
9. Compared with ph 7, Ph 9/10 is closer to already well populated DHA ph 1 to 4. Moreover, many plots of ph 9/10 will be closer to ph 5 too, when comparing distance with phase 7’s remotest blocks.
10. THE ONLY ADVANTAGE ph 7 has is it’s possession will be before DHA ph 9/10 but that early possession will be PRACTICALLY USELESS FOR MOST owners as there are two unpopulated phases 6 and 8 that have to be populated before DHA ph 7 can get populated. So possession will be given for ph 7 but will not be used by most owners as first homes will be made in ph 8 and ph 6, and after that in ph 7. By the time ph 7’s turn will come in full swing, phase 9/10 will be ready too, and will certainly be preferred over ph 7 due to ph 9/10’s better location, newer town-planning and most modern development with latest features, amenities and IMPROVEMENTS over the older phases.
11. In the long run ph 9/10 being closer to populated phases 1 to 4 and many other populated housing schemes will get inhabited more quickly than DHA ph 7, and thereby, in five to ten years time average ph 9/10 plot will likely be much more expensive than average DHA 7 plot.
12. So, the conclusion is you should chose ph 7 plot only if you want to make home in coming 3 to 4 years (but it will likely be in a largely deserted phase because of ph 8 and 6 being ahead of it with better locations). Otherwise, for long-term investment purpose DHA PH 9/10 IS CLEARLY THE WINNER. REASON: In the worst case you will not lose much, and in the best case you will get best returns on your investment. This is called LOW RISK HIGH REWARD investment.
M. Saqib Khan replied on Monday, August 13, 2007 08:01 PM PST
Excellent analysis. Thanks for your guidance. |
Ahmed replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 02:03 AM PST
Dear nice hard work and realistic analyses but be ready people will run at you. great work |
Syed replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 02:40 AM PST
Excellent assessments. Great visions.Thanks. |
Habib replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 02:21 PM PST
Dear Analyst How do you compare price of 9/10 in 17+12=29 vs phase 7 in 31, Price of 17 Lac is just illusion infact price is Miimum 29 may be more, There are hidden developmeent charges in 9/10 which are minimum 12 or may be more. |
Shahid Rasul replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 04:15 PM PST
One thing nobody realised that Phase 7 is gona be a part of Phase6,7,8. It is going to kind of huge city in its own. While Phase 9 will be an isolated phase. This thing will phase7 better than phase 9. Also there is going be a quicker rate of return in phase 7. |
Ali replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 05:09 PM PST
It is not correct to say phase 9-10 is isolated. phase 9/10 starts very next to phase 5 on one side and very close or next to Dha phase 4 on the other side. There will definitely be through roads from phase 1-4 and 5 connecting to phase 9-10. Geographically phase 7 is isolated from phase 1-4 but phase 9-10 right next to 1-4. Even if it was isolated being phase of proper Dha and at better location than phase 7, phase 9-10 would still be much better investment at meaker price of 17 lakh.
Dha gives only 1 kanal for 4 or 5 kanal of land taken from farmers. So the raw land price of phase 9-10 comes out to be only 4 lakh per kanal which is a joke as actual price of raw land there is much more. One of my friend sold some land near kahna for 8.50 lacs per kanal. That was raw land very far from city. Dha 9-10 is definitely under-priced at 17 lakh. Just the name Dha is worth more than 25 lakh. Dha 9-10 when developed should be at least 75 lakh. |
abc replied on Tuesday, August 14, 2007 07:40 PM PST
very American style rosy picture of DHA 9/10. writer seems to me very professional. i'm still not interested in dha 9/10. good luck ! |
|
|
 Tuesday, August 7, 2007 10:52 AM PST Reply: 
dear cmy and salman A khan sir pl give some advise i have plot in dha 7 in w block i bought it at 62 lac in 2005 now what can i do how much i wait to cover my money waiting for reply thank u sir
CMY replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 11:43 AM PST
My guess is you will have to wait 3-5 years to recover your loss. |
Salman A. Khan replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 02:08 PM PST
Sana Butt sahiba,
You have not given any idea of the location of your plot! According to my information the prevailing rate for an average plot in W block phase 7 is around 42/43 lacs with most sellers demanding around 45 lacs.In the last few days there has been an upsurge of queries though.
I personally feel that you should reach your purchase level in a period of 1 to 2 years maximum. Some reasons for my optimism are as follows:
Brigadier Bashir , An absolute honest and a thorough professional with an extremely strong personality is due to take over as the new administrator of Dha lahore on or about the 15th of August (less than a week away).He was awarded the sword of honour during his training period..(the highest award a cadet can be given ). I have heard his colleagues say that he will set things right in a matter of days.
For one thing, the development works (in phases 6 and 7) will be expedited and you will see how quickly positive events/developments can take place if the intentions are noble.
At present DHA phase 6's professed handing over is a farce. How can you hand over plots without providing even basic utilities! Phase 7 can only rise if phase 6 plots' prices rise. The impact of handing over of phase 6 ,pricewise, has yet to manifest itself. When investors actually see a proper handing over of Phase 6 with the availability of all utilities and a completed infrastructure than only will one witness a real substantial jump in phase 6 prices.This in turn will affect phase 7 prices also. Also under the new administration I expect phase 7 to be developed at an extremely fast pace.
The second main reason for my optimism is the launching of REITS!(the final regulations are being hatched out and by October 2007 one can expect these funds to start purchasing real estate in a big way) Mr. CMY has already given the viewers loads of extremely useful information on REITS (Real estate investment trusts)in his past posts!.Suffice to say only a very few nations of the world have such funds and they will attract lots of fresh investment from all over the world because they will provide a secure, regulated and streamlined means of real estate investment in Pakistan which even western investors can avail of!(this facilty is not even availbale in India).
And lastly I feel the owners of the malaysian golf course project Bandar raya ,which is being developed at an an extremely impressive pace, have an understanding with Dha Lahore that the phases W and V of phase 7 should be developed in tune with the golf course project.How can one have a finished multi-million dollars project in an undeveloped or under developed area? They have already launched their Houses project and are in the process of launching their luxury apartments project (Concordia).The prices of their project houses and apartments are extremely high which must and will in due course (especially) affect the prices of these two sectors of phase 7 W and V.
P.S.
I am quite sure a lot of readers will not agree with my views and be highly critical of them and accuse of me of projecting phase 6 and 7 because I own plots there; but by now I have become quite accustomed to criticsm and this is my own sincere objective appraisal! |
Asim replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 03:27 PM PST
Salman sb,
I have been reading your posts from last one year or more and I have noticed one thing in your personality which is very dominating, please do not get offended as the purpose to highlight it only because I want you to keep contributing to this page in much better way. I feel that you are very sensitive and short tempered person, you get offended very quickly. Take example of your yesterday’s post where you asked CMY to ban your permanently from this website. I mean if CMY and his team are posting DHA adds, irrespective the project is very expensive or whatever, it’s their job, they get business with the help of this page. We should in fact thank them that they allow everyone to post their Adds on their page and even everyone can discuss his views freely. If they removed your post yesterday, may be they felt that this could affect their business or probably that post was very much against DHA administration that’s why they deleted it. It’s army rule in Pakistan, I am sure CMY and team would not like someone banning their website which eventually can affect their business as well.
Again, please do not get offended, if you feel that I am wrong in my understanding, I apologize, but please have some courage to listen and understand. Patience is a great power and seldom people have it.
Best wishes.
Asim |
jnzi replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 04:43 PM PST
On the upcoming REITs in Pakistan and all the optimism associated with it, can somebody answer a simple question?
How does a REIT make money by buying plots??
There is no reoccuring rental value from a file or a plot! and REITs need to pay cash back to its investors.
Ok, yes, a REIT can buy land, build residential / commercial property and then make money - great - but this money will come from 1) RENTs and RENTS are not going UP, 2) developing and selling new housing colonies --> resulting in drop of prices of existing schemes by flooding the market.
In my opinion, this REIT revolution and its proclaimed impact on files / plots is a farce - just a pump up strategy to paint a rosey picture in the future and to trap innocent buyers. |
Ahmed replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 05:16 PM PST
REITs are extremely good for real estate market in Pakistan. There is a shortage of hundreds of thousands of homes in Pakistan. REITs can invest directly in construction of residential and commercial property, and make money for their investors.
Rent is only one way of making money from real estate. The Toyota, Honda or Suzuki companies which are listed in stock exchanges do not give cars on rent to make money for their investors. They make cars and sell them. Similarly REITs can invest in major housing projects which is very good for overall real estate market. This will benefit investors in plots directly and files indirectly. |
CMY replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 07:07 PM PST
Salman A Khan sahib I have said it before and will say it again. I have most respect for your views than any one else here. I love to read each word of your posts. Most of the information in your posts have become true in past. It will be a tragedy to loose your posts here.
But plz you should also understand I have many limitations here. This site could be banned in Pakistan for posts like you had here yesterday. We had been blocked by Govt once before and Its not done officially. They have many ways to show their power. I had to make very expensive arrangement to trick that blockage.
Please be a little more polite in your posts. We both could help more people by keeping this page on line. Please also note I had given powers to many moderators to delete the posts. I only give this power to very responsible persons to people. Half of the moderators are pro property gains and other half are people that have views that are very different than mine.I myself alone cant run this page smoothly. I need help of moderators daily to keep this page on line. I also have to follow the rules I have made for others. My posts now get deleted by these moderators. Even though the post of Salman sahib has no dirty language in it but It had very hard words and charges against DHA admin. If that post by Salman A Khan sahib was not removed in time by a moderator It could have caused a major trouble for this web page and we may have to close this page at higher authorities orders if we need to live peacefully in Pakistan.
Salman sahib Its easy for you to say what ever you like without disclosing your identity. But what ever you say is posted on LahoreRealEstate.Com and we are held responsible for display of all your and other friends postings. Now many powerful people do visit this page and we get calls immediately for other persons posts. Let me give you a hint. This web page is now read by most property developers heads, and high ups.
These moderators control 100s of other spam type posts. I have very clear policy of deletion. If post is against any person or not related to property It is deleted. Please understand these moderators are helpings all of us to have this wonderful opportunity to interact with each others.
Salman A Khan sahib I apologize for deletion of your post by a moderator but please dont mind it because your post had harsh words that were a little too strong for this site. |
Salman A. Khan replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 09:13 PM PST
CMY sahib,
I have the utmost respect for not just you, but also your brothers Abid and Naveed sahib. Since you have explained everything so politely and in such a gentle and frank manner ; I have no choice left but to thank you.
I would just like to add that I too have received threatening visits at my residence by certain officials more than once and it is only due to the intervention/support of certain sincere relatives and friends that I am still at liberty. You must understand though that I am an elderly person of very old fashioned values.I am sorry but I cant change my values in this last period of my life.I will ofcourse try and have sincerely tried in the past also to restrain myself but as someone said and I quote "You cant teach an old dog new tricks".If and when I write something that is unacceptable then I guess the moderators will just have to delete it.
Thank you once again for your gentle and detailed letter. It just proves your high breeding and gentlemanly character!
May God keep us all safe! |
sana butt replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 10:07 PM PST
sir my plot no is 249 w pl tell me the price of this thank u |
Muhammad Jameel replied on Tuesday, August 7, 2007 11:54 PM PST
Dear Salman Sahib, we admit that you have some insight in DHA office possibaly you have been working there or in army [you never disclosed] all of us enjoy your optimistc comments but none of your information /speculations has been found to be true.
Like you gave earth breaking news that DHA 7 development charges has been reduced to 6 Lac [totally wrong]. 9 Months back you speculated that DHA 8 file will lose and Phase 7 Plot will Gain [found to be totally wrong], 1 year Back You told Z block of DHA7 is very good and Gain too much it is now down to earth. You told that DHA 5 is already 80% populated [It is not even 8% Populated].
How sana can Trust You. |
Naveed Yaseen replied on Wednesday, August 8, 2007 04:07 AM PST
> none of your information/speculations has been found to be true.
Dear Jameel sahib, Salman sahib's information/assessments have been correct many times, most of times.
I do not think he ever predicted phase 8 will loose (he always talked in relative terms that compared to phase 8 he would prefer phase 7, which is different thing than loss or gain). I also do not remember him saying that Z block is very good or DHA 5 is 80% populated. If you think he said these things, references will be appreciated.
> all of us enjoy your optimistc comments
Can't say about others, but I not only enjoy his comments but get benefit from his posts and learn a lot too.
Regards |
tzk replied on Wednesday, August 8, 2007 06:43 AM PST
CMY,
is this the reason you are aggressively promoting DHA these days? Just kidding. I fully understand your situation.
These thugs think they can silence people. They dont understand "diya bijhay to sehr ho gi - sada dabay gi to hashr ho ga" |
Salman A. Khan replied on Wednesday, August 8, 2007 11:32 AM PST
Dear Naveed sahib,
Thank you so much for your encouraging words.They mean a lot to me!
And Dear Mr Mohd.Jameel sahib...As you have so rightly pointed out that I have been totally wrong in the past in all my predictions so now The law of Averages does suggest that I may very well be right this time.(smile).
p.s. I think I have on more than one occasion told the viewers that I am a retired (since 1995)grade 18 civil servant of extremely humble origins.(My rigid and non compromising personality and the utter lack of social skills contributed heavily to my not rising above the 18th grade even after more than three decades in government service.(smile).I was born in 1935 in India and migrated with my family to Pakistan at the time of partition!
As far as trusting me is concerned Jameel sahib I am just an ordinary hard hit investor like most of those who visit this site. Since I was asked by name to give my comments I dared to oblige.I am no property expert. (I have stated this over and over again).And I am quite sure no one on this forum makes any property related decisions based on my views. But I feel obliged to share whatever information (however incorrect it may turn out to be later) does come my way.It is all done with good intentions and no selfish motives.
Thank you for pointing out my short comings.I realise your intentions are sincere and your desire is only that viewers of this forum should not be misled by what ever information I relate.
Sincerely |
CMY replied on Wednesday, August 8, 2007 07:35 PM PST
I have confirmed from my sources new administrator of DHA Lahore will be here around 15th of August. |
MJK replied on Wednesday, August 8, 2007 09:39 PM PST
Nice to read all the above discussions. But Sana Butt's question is still not answered yet. I am not expert so someone like Mr. CMY or Mr. Salman can answer this. |
|
| 8133) | |
| CMY |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Saturday, July 28, 2007 11:06 AM PST Reply: 
What are Real Estate Investment Trusts? Here is some info
SECP finalises draft to bring in REITs as alternative asset class
ISLAMABAD (July 27 2007): Pakistan corporate regulator plans to introduce a specialised mutual fund to help regulate the real estate business by bringing it under the umbrella of stock trading, said a top official. The Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) has decided to bring in the Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) as an alternative asset class in the country.
The REITs is a specialised mutual fund that sells like a stock and primarily invests in the real estate. It is usually a company that offers common shares to the public. A REIT stock is similar to any other one that represents ownership in an operating business.
A mutual fund is a form of collective investments that pools money from many investors in stocks, bonds, short-term money market instruments, and/or other securities. Salman Ali Shaikh, the commissioner at the specialised companies division of the SECP, told Business Recorder on Thursday that a draft to introduce such a regulation has been finalised.
The commission, he said, has now publicised the proposed parameters to seek public opinion. "We have placed it on the web site and (we) will start writing about 100 letters to concerned individuals and organisations to improve the draft," Shaikh added.
The SECP will then finalise and formally introduce the regulation within 30 days. The reasonable input from the public as well as experts will be incorporated in the draft. The SECP will initially introduce the REITs in three major cities - Islamabad, Karachi and Lahore. Other towns will then be included gradually. Potential investors will have to buy land for floating the REIT fund.
According to a document Shaikh provided to this writer, the REIT Regulations, 2007 will help increase the inflows of foreign direct investment (FDI) into Pakistan. The foreign investors are at the moment reluctant to enter the unstructured market especially where real estate scandals have caused mistrust. Experts believe it will also discourage the sale and purchase of land only on papers. The document says domestic investors will follow a structured route under the REITs framework.
The combination of an equity security and real estate will offer an alternative asset class to investors. Shaikh said amendments made in the 1984 Company Ordinance through the Finance Bill, 2007 empowered the SECP to make such regulations under its regulatory jurisdiction.
Pakistan, Ali claimed, would become the first country to introduce the stock trading of real estate businesses among the so-called emerging economies. At the moment, this system is in place only in the United Stated, Europe and parts of Asia. Rapidly growing economies like India, Vietnam and Philippines still lack such a law.
http://www.brecorder.com/index.php?id=597123
|
|
 Saturday, July 7, 2007 05:06 PM PST Reply: 
*** Updated: Saturday, July 7, 2007 4:30 PM *** LRE Market Pulse ( Rates You Can Trust ) -
DHA Lahore Phase 5 Ext: Buyer(s) at 31.75 Seller(s) at 32.25 Lacs -
DHA Lahore Phase 8 Allocation: Buyer(s) at 41.90 Seller(s) at 42.40 Lacs -
DHA Lahore Phase 9/10 Allocation: Buyer(s) at 17.30 Seller(s) at 17.55 Lacs -
State Life Phase 2 Proper, 8-Paid, 1-Kanal: Buyer(s) at 12.65 Seller(s) at 12.75 Lacs -
State Life Phase 2 Membership, 6-Paid, 1-Kanal: Buyer(s) at 9.65 Seller(s) at 9.75 Lacs -
Bahria Town Phase 9, 3-Paid, 10-Marla: Buyer(s) at 1.70 Seller(s) at 1.73 Lacs -
Bahria Town Phase 9, 2-Paid, 10-Marla: Buyer(s) at 1.20 Seller(s) at 1.23 Lacs For less frequently changed rates in other housing societies/cities please visit: LRE Property Prices Snapshot @ http://www.LahoreProperty.com Rates You Can Trust Data Provided By Lahore Real Estate. *** To Buy/Sell Plots & Files in DHA Lahore, please Call (+92-42-) 111-111-040, or Email: LRE786@GMail.com ***
Qasim replied on Saturday, July 7, 2007 09:36 PM PST
CMY Sb, DHA-8 has been on the rise for some days. Is there any particular reason for this rise? Any rumers for balloting etc? Thanks, |
CMY replied on Saturday, July 7, 2007 11:10 PM PST
I will explain the reasons why heavy buying is seen in DHA 8 and DHA 9-10. |
donmakepeoplefool replied on Sunday, July 8, 2007 11:53 AM PST
What heavey buyer, people are dying there, they killing each other, price should go down, do not make people fool mr. American. |
CMY replied on Sunday, July 8, 2007 10:31 PM PST
Dear Mr Pakistani donmakepeoplefool friend :) You should have waited to hear details my side before making the judgment.
Two weeks ago if you had 22.50 lacs you could have bought DHA 7 plot instead of DHA 9-10 file. You would say I won’t buy a file and why not buy a plot in DHA 7 at only 22.50 lacs current budget. Price difference between 9-10 and DHA 7 was only 5 lacs. Since 2 weeks ago DHA put restriction again that all DHA 7 plot will be transferred all dues cleared. No one is able to buy DHA 7 if he don't have 32 lacs in hand on transfer day. So people under 32 lacs budget have no choice but to go for DHA 9-10. Price difference today for DHA 9-10 and DHA 7 is 15 lacs. Either DHA 9-10 will rise to min 22 lacs very shortly or DHA 7 will have to fall to 27 lacs to close the big gap to within 10 lacs. DHA 9-10 is better located than DHA 7. Look at DHA phases location map little closer and you will know what I am talking about. What do you think DHA 7 will go again to 27 lacs and same time DHA 9-10 will have to stay at 17.50 lacs? Not possible in my opinion.
Why DHA 8 rose?
After development charges are needed at time of transfer announcement from DHA admin only a fool will buy a plot in DHA 7 if he has over 42 lacs in his pockets. All smart persons go for DHA 8 in that budget of 41 plus lacs. So heavy buying is happening here. New road from Air Avenue to DHA 6 main boulevard at L and J block junction is showing up on ground. UD is making that connection road at urgent bases. That road and new expressway fro defence road in middle of DHA 8 are helping DHA 8 files and when DHA files gain value DHA 9-10 us purchased too by low budget people and its price go up too.
Other factor all friend are forgetting is real estate trust that will come into play by end of this year. I need more time to explain there timing and playing field. I request friends to please start learning researching and education each other on REITs. After more Friends know more about it I will write more details about. For now I just want to let you know these Real estate trusts will have to buy property before selling it. If you are smart you will get the idea what Ia m talking about. By Dec Jan there will be plenty of buyers that are sitting out to clear up every thing. From who will you buy your files and plot when market is rising and these trusts are buying properties? Smart people are buying now when files and plots are still available. Not much time is left before the next wave of buying. get ready for very sharp rise in property prices by Nov Dec this year. The moment prices start to go up half sellers back out from any sale in hope to sell their property higher. Other half are bought on byana by my my property dealer friends. Real investor than are forced to pay many lacs more that they should have paid.
If you have money to invest in property and ready to buy but looking for things to clear up first before buying . My request to you is to act before Oct 2007 end and complete your buying or in my opinion you will have to pay much higher for same property.
People are not afraid of buying any more like they were last year when prices where falling like knife. People are willing to buy but want to know what is right time to get in. They are afraid of political situation CJ issue and Lal Masjad etc. But like I said smart people who do research and have seen things change on ground like Major new roads in middle of DHA 8 and DHA 6 plots possession have started to act now on buying side before its too late for them. They were all hoping the prices will fall after Lal Masjad attack when they fail to fall these guys realized market is strong from inside and time to start buying now than in Oct Nov Dec 2007.
Dear Mr donmakepeoplefool friend you should take time out and try to learn and research Real Estate Investment Trusts so we could take more about them in my next post. Its time for Pakistan to move to next step.
((((((Real estate investment trust?)))))))))
REITs can be classified as equity, mortgage or hybrid.
A Real Estate Investment Trust or REIT (rēt, rhymes with treat) is a tax designation for a corporation investing in real estate that reduces or eliminates corporate income taxes. In return, REITs are required to distribute 90% of their income, which may be taxable in the hands of the investors. The REIT structure was designed to provide a similar structure for investment in real estate as mutual funds provide for investment in stocks.
Like other corporations, REITs can be publicly or privately held. Public REITs may be listed on public stock exchanges like shares of common stock in other firms.
The key statistics to look at in REIT are its NAV (Net Asset Value), AFFO (Adjusted Funds From Operations) and CAD (Cash At Disposal).
Qualifications
REITs will have to be established as a corporation "REIT-AG" or "REIT-Aktiengesellschaft".
At least 75% of its assets have to be invested in real-estate.
At least 75% of the G-REIT's gross revenues must be real-estate related.
At least 90% of the REIT's taxable income has to be distributed to its shareholders through dividends.
The corporation is income-tax-exempt, but the shareholders will have to pay individual income tax on the dividends.
Indian REITs
India is currently in the process of formulating definitive legislation for the introduction and smooth functioning of REITs in the Indian real estate market. Once introduced these Indian REITs (country specific/generic version I-REITs) will help individual investors enjoy the benefits of owning an interest in the securitised real estate market. The best benefit being that of fast and easy liquidation of investments in the real estate market unlike the traditional way of disposing real estate. The government and Securities and Exchange Board of India SEBI through various notifications is in the process of easing the norms of investing in real estate in India directly and indirectly through foreign direct investment, through listed real estate companies, mutual funds etc. With the current real estate boom and the market being flooded with Initial Public Offer of various listed real estate companies in India it will be the best time for investors to own a share of the profiting market economy. Legislative framework, revised investment norms and a favourable investment opportunity, and a clear taxation policy will provide the right kind of investing opportunity in India in the time to come.
United States REITs
See also: List of public REITs in the United States
In the U.S., REITs generally pay little or no federal income tax, but are subject to a number of special requirements set forth in the Internal Revenue Code, one of which is the requirement to annually distribute at least 90% of its taxable income in the form of dividends to its shareholders.
In recent practice, many REITs distribute all of or even more than their current earnings, often resulting in dividend yields comparable to bond yields. If an investment company such as a REIT distributes more than its taxable income, the excess distribution is considered "return of capital" for tax purposes (not taxed as ordinary income, but first reduces basis in REIT stock; if this brings the basis to zero, then remaining amount of the return on capital is taxed at capital gain rates). The distribution requirement may hamper a REIT's ability to retain earnings and generate growth from internal resources. This and other restrictions imposed by the Internal Revenue Code generally limit a REIT's suitability for growth-oriented investors. However, other considerations may result in potential for stock price appreciation, such as improvements in the REITs underlying leasing markets, changes in interest rates or increasing demand for REIT stocks.
As of early 2005, there were nearly 200 publicly traded REITs operating in the United States. Their assets included a combined $500 billion, and approximately two-thirds of them were trading on national stock exchanges. The number of REITs not registered with the Securities Exchange Commission and not publicly traded is about 800.[1]
Qualification
In order to qualify for the advantages of being a pass-through entity for U.S. corporate income tax, a REIT must:
Be structured as corporation, trust, or association[3]
Be managed by a board of directors or trustees[4]
Have transferable shares or transferable certificates of interest[5]
Otherwise be taxable as a domestic corporation[6]
Not be a financial institution or an insurance company[7]
Be jointly owned by 100 persons or more[8]
Have 95 percent of its income derived from dividends, interest, and property income[9]
Pay dividends of at least 90% of REIT's taxable income
No more than 50% of the shares can be held by five or fewer individuals during the last half of each taxable year
At least 75% of total investment assets must be in real estate
Derive at least 75% of gross income from rents or mortgage interest
Have no more than 20% of its assets consist of stocks in taxable REIT subsidiaries.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_estate_investment_trust |
CMY replied on Sunday, July 8, 2007 10:39 PM PST
I have tried my best to explain the reasons for recent rise in DHA 8 and DHA 9-10 files. There are more reason behind this rise but due to lack of time I am unable to write more details. Sorry again for misspell bad grammar etc. I was in hurry to post this answer before going to bed. I don't know If Ia was able to make my point in way that was understandable to all friends. I will try my best to find spare time to write easy to read and understand post about current market inside and near future price trend hopes.
Time to have some sleep. Good night. |
Shahid Hanif replied on Monday, July 9, 2007 12:26 AM PST
Thanks CMY. You are the best. Nothing compare to you. |
Sabir replied on Monday, July 9, 2007 01:00 AM PST
Dear CMY,
I always like your analysis, great job. Please comment on DHA 5 ext. |
Shahid Rasul replied on Monday, July 9, 2007 01:30 AM PST
One has to be careful about Phase 8 and 9-10.
1. An investment in phase 9-10 will take at least 10 years to mature. That means you spend around 20 lac to buy a file and later on will end up paying 15-20 lac in development charges. In 10 years even if you double it to 80 lac, your profit will be 10% per year. This is the best you are going to get from phase 9-10.
2. Investment is phase 8 is very risky. You buy a file for 41 lac, pay one lac transfer charges and later on pay 12 lac development charges. Your total cost will be 54 lac for one kanal plot in phase 8. Now most people do not realise that there is a possibility that you may get a plot near village or Nala. Who is going to but a plot in 55 lac on Nala or near a village. Good plots like corner ones and facing parks are usually taken out of the ballot. Since there are lot of high profile army officers involved in phase 8, your best bet is to get an average plot in phase 8. Now just ask yourself that if you would like a worst or average plot for min of 54 lac or buy a best location plot in phase 7 for 45 lac or for 65 lac in phase 6.
Just give it a thought. |
Shahid Rasul replied on Monday, July 9, 2007 02:00 AM PST
Also phase 8 is going to be the most polluted phase in DHA in future. It is going to take all the traffic load for phase 5,6 and 7. Just observe phase 1 main blvd after 3PM and you will get an idea that how ugly it will for phase 8. There are going to be lot more houses in phase 6 alone than all existing houses in DHA now.
Other factors for phase 8 will be traffic noise, airport noise, more dust for phase 8.
Phase 8 is not going to be a good phase for living. Quality of living is going to be better in phase 6 and 7. It may give you some return if your motive is investment but you have to be very careful with your exit timing. |
jnzi replied on Monday, July 9, 2007 02:52 PM PST
Dear CMY!
useful information on REITs.
However, please shed more light on how REITs will make money on files / plots?
If a REIT has to give out its profits in terms of dividends, then it needs to generate these profits.
For contrusted business premises & private housing, there are monthly returns generated from rents. However from plots and specially files, where are these monthly returns coming from?
If these so called Pakistani "REITs" will invest in empty plots and files, and generate returns based on turnover / flipping of these files & plots - this is exactl what the "cooperatives" did a decade ago before failing and taking huge sums from innocent people.
So, in my opinion, the government would have to regulate REITs so that the investments made by these REITs are not focused on flipping of plots and files. If this is not done, then REITs would just be a legal way to create massive fruad that could easily be declared bankrupt when the files & plot prices crash.
jnzi |
fourvoyagers replied on Monday, July 9, 2007 03:45 PM PST
Assalam-o-Alaikum,
All said and done, but time will prove these fancy looking REITs to be nothing but a pack of growling wolves hidden in skin of sheep. I think people should be bracing themselves for yet another scam, in which billions will be swallowed even without a belch!!! |
Qasim replied on Monday, July 9, 2007 06:26 PM PST
CMY Sb, as always thanks for comprhensive response. |
|
| 8131) | |
| guest |
| | City & Country: - | |
 Sunday, July 1, 2007 05:17 AM PST Reply: 
farhan replied on Sunday, July 1, 2007 03:00 PM PST
yes very much true.because the same thing happened after 9/11,but looking at the current situation off pakistan would people wantto invest there???
however home is home what ever the situation.
pakistan is a paradise if u have money but if u dont its the opposite.
most pakistanis living in u.k are on state benefits and cant afford to move back,u.k. is a heaven for them,free housing ,free money ,free food etc etc etc.the working person doesnt get these benefits as most of his money goes towards taxes.only my views no offence to anyone.
regards farhan. |
Waseem Malik replied on Sunday, July 1, 2007 07:26 PM PST
very interesting Farhan. I never knew that “most Pakistanis living in u.k are on state benefits and cant afford to move back”. I agree with you. if that’s the case, they will never leave free food and shelter.
Here in Canada, its totally opposite. its rare to find someone from Pakistan on state benefits. Majority is highly educated and play important role in country economy by working hard and paying taxes. |
Views replied on Sunday, July 1, 2007 07:47 PM PST
Is it your wish?
Now it will take decades to happen again. |
atiq raja. replied on Sunday, July 1, 2007 09:09 PM PST
yes,i settled in uk and have good business ,but i prefer to settle in
islamabad,not in other part of country,i will build a house in e/11,
today i confirm the prices of e/11 for 500 sqyd plot which are 2 crore
to 125 crore in nfp and multi(phase1),110 to 115 crore for fedration and i crore to 110 for multi(phase2) |
khan from canada replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 12:44 AM PST
Totally seconding Waseem about CANADIAN PAKISTANIES. I would not say all of them but most of them are well setteled and have very good jobs and definetly are well educated. And interestingly, even though they are well setteled in Canada, they would be and are moving back to Pakistan in big numbers (keeping in view the the good economy of Pakistan), specially those who have families not immigrating to Canada. |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 01:17 AM PST
I do wish from the bottem of my heart that all my Muslim/Pakistani brothers would leave the KAFIRS countries and establish London and New york in Pakistan. Our Pakistan. |
Doctor replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 03:34 AM PST
Dear Mr. Guest
Which country you are talking about? The country of Mafias, where no law and order and no respect of life. I lived 6 years in Karachi. I know what state of living was in Karachi and Pakistan. I am living in UK and I am pleased that I have no tension. My kids and family they are safe and no body can point finger toward us. Sorry to say that for vested interests people are just spreading these rumours. Pakistanies living here are very much integrated here and contributing very well. We Pakistanis are very much established and no plans to move back in this total unrest and injustice social set-up.
Sorry for any disrespect |
choudhry72 replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:01 AM PST
dear doctor dont be sory,
every town centre in uk is full of half naked pakistani girls, who dont know how to speak urdu. speak english like goras..think they r goras while goras think of them as low life pigs.
we r sory for you |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:37 AM PST
Doctor sahib I am sorry but choudhry72 sahib is 100% true. It burns my heart to think and see all this when I visit London and Manchester. The niggers and the white skinned people look at us and treat us like some kind of infections/sewer rats that have forcefully been put on them. People with no soul can only live in such a society. People who are hungry for only money. That is the truth. I tell you with ALLAH as my witness I fell and am treated 1 million times batter in my Pakistan than I did over there and am loved by my country and I love it. From the bottom of the heart no Brit or Yankee wana bee (Pakistani) can say that. |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:39 AM PST
in London or Amarica. |
sk replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:44 AM PST
Interesting disucussion. Every country has pros and cons, one has to accept realities in every country. I wont get into what happens in Pakistan in terms of english or urdu or half naked or full. Let ppl live how they want to live and you live your life. |
Sohail London replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:46 AM PST
Mr Choudry, You comments made me sad and your language tell a lot about your background, get some life. Firstly I don't wish all the best to my Pakistanis brothers and sisters in UK are peaceful and doing a great help for Pakistan by sending vital remittances through proper channels .
I have been living in UK and know lots of great Pakistanis who helped with millions of pounds providing aid for Pakistan on humanitarian grounds. But I can assure you one thing that here ground realities are different from day dreamers, who think all Pakistanis will leave a peaceful country just to invest in Pakistan.
Sorry and keep dreaming and try to help your country rather then just praying someone’ s de-stability will bring prosperity to Pakistan.
Sorry that’s not only sick but inhuman as well. |
Khan..True pakistani replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:54 AM PST
Choudhry sb,
These half naked girls are 100 times better than mafia/political party workers in pakistan...they dont interfere in our lives....what is happening in close doors in pakistan we all know? call girls? mujras? alcohol? homos? dating in cafe's? hostage cases in masjids, even police being kidnapped? shia sunnis killing eash other? who got killed like pigs on May 12th? whos sleeping on the roads,drug addicts and got quashed on the roads and dead bodies are on edhi's mercy?bribe in all depts? clean water? electricity? security? even pay for the burial?theft/ rebberies?can u argue with any builder for possesion?free medical? education quality? i bet u leave your your sister, daughter or wife alone in your home and a peacfull dinner alone?can you wife or sister walk or go out at 3 at early morning, even in emergency ? here in UAE or in overseas they can. we know how many pakistanis wish to forget urdu and start speaking english in pakistan? no english, no jobs in overseas pra jee.i bet you dont know the quality of an average indian working in finance,IT and marketing...pakistanis are no where in terms of educational and communicational skills... unfortunetly goras are following our steps in community services dear. I wish pakistan can have simple and basic needs and rights for its citizens.I can or any true pakistani write on for ages on this issu....no pakistani wants to leave their beloved country....but we all know why we want to...its so easy to blame each other..... but we all know where pakistan is standing today. Pakistan today is only surviving because of our shaheeds and dua's of our elders and people who gave their lives so we can live and talk about DHA..DHA and Porperty and property......
Admin do not delete this messege.....have guts |
khan..True pakistani replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 05:01 AM PST
sorry for the errors in typing...missed lots of words while expressing me self..... |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 05:05 AM PST
Khan sahib that is a very impressive reply. Why don’t you stop moaning and come here and fix something instead of running to Dubai with your tail in between your legs. If you were a true Pakistani you wouldn’t talk about Pakistan but you would come here and fight the Mafia and the tyrants.
When reading Sohail’s comments I think.
Hazrat Ali's comments.( A nation can survive on QOFAR but not on injustice) |
Shahid replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 08:10 AM PST
I believe it is you Mr guest who has tail in between legs. You even do not want to reveal your name. |
Tauseef replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 10:35 AM PST
Mr.guest, what is the definition of a true Pakistani? A person who is living in Pakistan...??? I am sorry to say but tell you onething, Mr. guest if you will get a chance of going abroad with proper documentation, you will be the one who will jump first.
Now donot tell be that you lived bla bla years abroad and came back to Pakistan...!!! because you love Pakistan. Its all opportunistic game. |
sajid Khan replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 12:37 PM PST
Dear Friends, A country is known by the people who occupies it, need not to say what kind of people we are. I have stayed in U.K during my college years and I know for a fact that the dirtiest things like travelling without a valid ticket, not paying road tax or insurance etc etc and the list is lenghty, is done by Pakistanis. The worst part is that they tend to stay away from Britons, it is said that " in Rome do what Romans do" I am not not saying that we change our culture etc but at least we can be friends and I can assure you that the Goras do respect our culture. The conflict arrises when we do respect their culture and take them for a ride. One more thing refering to Mr. Guest or Quest, If all of Pakistanis come back to Pakistan, Pakistan will doome to exisit ( earlier than predicted) as foreign remittances is a major source of income for the country and balances the trade deficit!!!!! The war of the religion is only limited to some people and we as common peple should focus on the well being of the state ( where ever we live in )and keep our lives simple! |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 01:08 PM PST
Ooh! But I am actually from the UK and spat at there money and passport and came back to my beloved Pakistan. If you don’t belive me that’s fine I only have one thing to say to you sir. You are a F_____ing B______ard. Y don’t u just stay there and marry some Gori for a green card. That’s the Okat of people like you.
sajid sahib my reply to u is the same one as khan sahib's y don't you come back and work here sacrifice your time and energy for the batterment of Pakistan. You are doing the same thing for the Kafirs y not Pakistan. |
Raheel Khan replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 01:15 PM PST
Dear All,
1) West donot want you muslims to develope, that they donot let you biuld nuclear reacters to produce cheap electricity ?
2) West has lauched WARs against muslims virtually in all muslims lands, now they are thinking of IRAN.
3) West want you to live in their societies if you follow their way of life. that secular way of life, where all is justified to acquire wordly gains.
4) Instead of arguing and blaming each other we need work alot internally for our country Pakistan and externally outside Pakistan to get the expertise and knowledge to build a strong Union of Islamic Countries like Europian union and united States.
5) Our motives shall be not to fight or launch WARs like the west has done the last centry, but to produce a strong Union of Islamic countries which respect other cultures and religions.
Best Regards,
Raheel Khan |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 01:25 PM PST
Raheel sahib you are a 100% true. Please read the comments of Raheel sahib carefully. |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 01:42 PM PST
Sajid Khan sahib if we work hard here and do business or some other kind of work that is healthy for our economy we will not need the pittens sent by overseas Pakistanis. |
Aman replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 02:14 PM PST
Mr. Raheel is right, in his 4th point he has suggested what we should do. This is only possible the moment every muslim starts giving up his right for his brother and secondly learn to forgive and forget among the brotherhood. Otherwise the situation is every person having his demands and killing each other for his/her rights. |
khan..real pakistani replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 02:23 PM PST
Quest,
Your language tells a lot about your background and you are a gora! using their slang language...right? iam sure you got a kick on a butt from gora thats why so much hatered. What have you done for pakistan while u were in UK? just threw ur passport and came to pakistan for what? what value addition till now u have done in pakistan? why did you leave pakistan in first place? or even ur parents if u were born there? hahahahha just relax brother...pray 5 times and follow huqquq al ibad.....thats enough for all of us and try to stay happy in ur life...which is very short and do book a small plot for urself and us in qabaristan buddy....thats our real(estate)investment.....and just try to read todays DAWN.COM headlines regarding our beloved pakistani group's bomb making bust........true appraisal of a pakistani nation? |
khan...real pakistani replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 02:26 PM PST
Quest...
Pls do read ad no 32649 by Mr Mujahid Rana....u will get your answer and pls do something as u r in pakistan and i will pray and donate max amount for our pakistan.... |
choudhry72 replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 03:27 PM PST
Khan..True pakistani
'These half naked girls are 100 times better than mafia/political party workers in pakistan...they dont interfere in our lives....'
thats your personal opinion, i beg to differ..
Sohail London :
'Sorry and keep dreaming and try to help your country rather then just praying someone’ s de-stability will bring prosperity to Pakistan'
spoken like true servant of her majesty,, by the way no body in my background has sold his and his families sole to be part of lowest socio - economic class of GREAT britain, who by the way was over taken last year by china and would be over taken in 6-7 years by india in terms of gdp. |
anar gul - pakistan replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 03:36 PM PST
i know atiq Raja, is poor pakistani in manchester. he is student and belong to very poor family, but he is talking here about millions.
90% pakistanis in british are FAQIRS , hand to mouth living.
wish them good luck. |
UK replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:05 PM PST
Guest says that he has been to UK for many years, but he doesn't know that there is no such thing as 'Green Card'. Its in USA not UK Mr Guest.
I agree with Mr khan that either guest was refused a visa or deported |
shahid replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 04:25 PM PST
Is hamam mein sab nangay hein,
every place has got its benifits and risks, we should choose on our own circumstancs rather than blaming others.
If I like living abroad, no one can force me to come back.
It depends what u like, mullas, military, security, development and civilised society. its all up to us what we choose.
Guys calm down .
there is no need to shout. Tolerance is islam. |
atiq raja. replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 06:09 PM PST
I am president area welfare comatiee,presededent PPP preston city and
chairman hackney carraige association city council preston,i dont know
the actual position of other coutries but in uk there is not good future for our new generation,but 90% people are struk to pay martgages,instalments i.e if you buy a house amount of 3 lack pouds
the monthly instalment would be 2400 pounds per month i.e 600 pounds per week and maximum labour wage is around 250 pounds per week,in these days earning of money is very deficult,how any one aford a good living in pakistan .. door key dhool sohynye................... |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 06:19 PM PST
ok Mr. UK, Bro I was thinking about America at the time and was a bit emotional. ALLAH as my witness I was not thrown out of London but left on my own accord. We were well settled we had a three bedroom house in Hays. My family thought it best for us to leave before we too loose our faith completely. I must be honest I didn't know what a Juma was over there and I didn’t even know how to pray. But thanks to ALLAH TALA now I am more of a Muslim over here than I was there.
Khan sahib I know you are having a laugh but I am serious. My Family field is in Medical all my Family is affiliated with Medicine and Doctors. We have given a lot of money to the needy. My family gives free care to the poor from villages and others who can not afford the expenses. That’s what we have done for Pakistan. What you have done is to send money to buy a plot in DHA and when the time was right you sold it and bought something more expensive. If anything u stopped the needy from buying a house which I know most of the people over here dream about. |
guest replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 06:32 PM PST
If there is a small fire in the US of London the news is posted here and we all have a jolly good discussion about it. I cant understand as to y people living in the UK failed to mention the Knighting of SALMAN RUSHTI (the guy who insulted the entire Muslim world) every paki brit should have condoned the knighting and there should have been a stand taken if not in the streets of London than at least on this Forum. But I think all of them were scared and had there tails in there legs, that may be the British Government was taping there Internet service and if they said anything they would be halled of to jail under the Law passed by Tony Blare which states that anyone or any Muslim can be kept under custody for 28 days with out charge. I pity such people.
You never bite the hand that feeds you, Right! my Paki brothers. |
Kashif replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 07:48 PM PST
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Learn three things if you really wants to bring change in pakistan!
Excuse me,Sorry And Thanks. |
Architect replied on Monday, July 2, 2007 11:46 PM PST
Dear Friends
There are problems in every country But we can not just sit in pakistan and do not go in the western countries.
Please go (if you can) to western countries because islam does not believe in land boundries, all the land belongs to Allah, But where ever you live, please live there responsibaly and keep your strong connection with ALLAH & Qur'aan And never forget Two things while you live specially in western World.
1..Spread the message of Allah in these non-muslim societies because its the main responsibility of muslims living in the west, Otherwise these western people and nations will SUE you guys in the day of Judgement in front Of ALLAH.
THese non Muslims will say to Allah in the day of Judgement that tese muslims kept this Message of Allah with them and they never practice it by themselves and they never conveyed it to the others.
2.. Get knowledge of Science from these western nations and use this knowledge for the Islamic nation in general and for pakistan in special.
And never forget we (muslims) gave this knowledge of science to these nations 500 years ago through Muslim Span.
After that we left this knowledge and these nations developed it and as a result we became slaves of these nations.
Everyone of us make a committment that InshaAllah by acting upon the the message of Allah, and by getting this knowledge of science we will again RISE & SHINE in the world and inshAllah we will deliver the message of Allah to every corner of this world.
May God Bless Muslims....Ameen. |
khan from canada replied on Tuesday, July 3, 2007 11:07 AM PST
Lets put an end to this useless discussion. Everybody has his or her own point of view. West has lots of good things that Pakistan doesn't and vice versa. Its one's personal choice and priority, as to which that person prefers- Thanks |
guest replied on Tuesday, July 3, 2007 01:39 PM PST
Khan sahib, it's cool bro. |
|
| 8130) | |
| jnzi |
| jnzi@yahoo.com | | Phone:9999 | City & Country: germany | |
 Thursday, June 28, 2007 04:27 PM PST Reply: 
Currency 1 year return 5 year return
Canadian Dollar 6.6% 46%
Australian Dollar 16.3% 50.6%
Euro 7.2% 39%
US Dollar 1% 1%
New Zealand Dollar 29% 61.5%
Brazilian Rial 15.5% 52%
Indian Rupee 14% 21%
Russian Ruble 5.8% 23.7%
Thai Baht 21.6% 33%
Chinease Yuan 6.1% 10.3%
Malaysian Ringget 6.7% 11.5%
Swiss Franc 2.9% 20.25%
Above returns are for the last one and five years in Pakistani currency.
Interesting to see the Newzealand dollar, australian dollar, the thai baht and even the Indian Ruppee performing so well.
This points to free float of the currency + strong performance of the economy + good management by the government and central banks (even Thailand!!)
we seem to be tied to the tail coat of the americans. and their currency is not going anywhere - which means we are depreciating versus major economies.
I posted these returns to suggest that investing in currencies is also a viable option as compared to real estate.
more on commodity prices later,
jnz
ua replied on Thursday, June 28, 2007 06:28 PM PST
I would very strongly advice people against investing in currency, specially for long term. You may earn by playing satta in short term but over long term, intrinsic value of every currency does depreciate. It is just that some currencies will depreciate faster than others and some smart investors (e.g. George Soros in 1992) have made money on this differential but for an ordinary investor, short time forex investment is a risky business. And over longer term, inflation will keep on eating each and every currency.
There are definitely viable investing options available. Stocks, bonds, term deposits, mutual funds to name a few but real estate is also one of the the viable options.
As this site is basically for real estate investment discussions so that's what gets mainly discussed here :) |
fourvoyagers replied on Saturday, June 30, 2007 11:45 AM PST
Assalam-O-Alaikum,
The Wiz Kids can make millions by investing in currency. But for ordinary folks its a complete disaster, as they have to be on their toes all the time. In fact people should be extremely careful investing in currency especially in places like Pakistan! |
|
|
 Thursday, June 14, 2007 10:03 PM PST Reply: 
Safari Villas Lahore – A Living Experience (Part 4) 
It is now almost a year when my family shifted in Safari Villas Lahore. There were always many positive additions here which kept on providing sense of great feeling to witness the development. A wonderful development, road networks, over security, parks, beautiful mosque, mini zoo, market, shops, restaurants, transport services, school, hospital, kids playing area and electricity availability round the clock. There are other good additions in the area and a PERMANENT CHANGE and constant improvement makes the Safari Villas enjoyable.
There are some new developments in Bahria Town Lahore which are also directly related to Safari Villas which I wanted to share with you.
1. The Meadows enhances the beauty of Bahria Town Lahore. There are worth visiting sites in the Meadows project which are in final stages.
2. Bahria Town School Lahore has been affiliated with Cambridge for its O level and A Level exams. Besides this it has affiliation with Agha Khan Board for Matric. The quality of education in School is satisfactory and fees structure is very much on low side. As per school's Principal Ms. Naghmana Ambreen, the fees are very much subsidized. Pick and drop for Safari residents is free.
3. New restaurants has been started. Yummy 36 is now serving better along with its Ice Cream Parlor and restaurant. De Olive Green has vast open area as it is situated in Shaheen Park.
4. Sham-e-Ghazal, Jashn-e-Baharan and Youm-e-Azadi March etc are the events which were arranged during last few months.
5. A very beautiful mosque is now completed. Juma prayer, Eid Namaz and Taraveeh can be offered in Safari Villas.
6. Bahria Town Management has started yearly white wash and coloring of all the villas without charging any thing from the owners.
7. Bahria Town Management has taken its responsibility to remove the problems in the making and construction. Almost every tile of my villas has been replaced. All the faults were considered by Bahria Town and they accept as their responsibility.
8. Movie Theater, Community Hall is under construction. Its speed of construction shows that these will be ready within next month.
A contract with AFC has been made and they are supposed to open their branch within next month.
9. AFC has a plan to have a general Store or Mart type of shop along with their Fried Chicken.
10. As Sui Gas bills were not accepted by PICIC bank so Bahria Town office is taking the responsibility of depositing these bills.
11. Hospital has more facilities as Specialists / Consultants are available in their clinics (within the hospital) from 8 AM to 4 PM. Emergency is function on 24 hours basis. Unfortunately we needed hospital facilities – both consultancy as well as Emergency – and we found it very professional and economical.
I do want to share with you my disappointments with Bahria Town.
1. They have almost stopped their completion work in Safari Villas as well as in Sector C. It seems that their work force as well as machinery remained busy either in The Meadows or in their project on Raiwind Road.
2. Though they take full responsibility of removing their construction faults but they are not quick in this regard. Their customer service for solving daily problems is VERY prompt and professional. It does happen that their team reaches on spot before returning of the complaint to his/her villa.
3. They are not able to provide PTCL phone lines to all the villas. Though they have provided V Wireless phones but many people are not comfortable with it due to its limitation (Mainly it does not have extension option).
4. Cable network in NOT under control of Bahria Management so their service is not upto the mark.
5. Internet Services are not yet provided by Bahria Town.
6. Life is NOT enjoyable in Safari Villas NOWADAYS due to too much electricity shut down. Bahia Town has totally FAILED in providing this facility during last three days. Their rates for electricity unit are on higher side and their service in this regard is pathetic.
Thanks for your time.
Visitor replied on Thursday, June 14, 2007 11:29 PM PST
Thanks for very valuable insight.
I think the only problem with Bahria has been its location, probably it is the farthest of all current and new socities. As far as development is concerned, it can be said that it matches that of DHA. And due to this location thing, most probably DHA will take away most of the international real estate investment (hotels, commercial buildings etc) like they have floated the opportunities in DHA-8 (parkview)recently in newspapers. |
tzk replied on Friday, June 15, 2007 08:02 AM PST
thanks very much for such detailed and unbiased/critical information.
Please tell bahria management that phone and internet are like blood for life these days. We can no survive without them. Most expats who are thinking of settling down in pakistan is because of these facilities. If we have highly reliable phone and high speed internet service(without interuption), a lot of pakistani people can move back and work from there. |
tzk replied on Friday, June 15, 2007 08:08 AM PST
Visitor & Ali
a few things
1. quality of development of bahria is way better than dha
2. a lot of people prefer dha for the name (status symbol)
3. new phases of dha are atleast as far from lahore as bahria.
4. approach to dha is not as good as bahria (multan road, canal, defence road)
5. distance these days is more of a psychological issue than a practical issue. A visit from gulberg to railway station will take more time than a visit from gulberg to bahria. similarly it is much faster to go to bahria from garden town, ichra, mall road, samanabad, mazand than to go to dha
6. Real ali, please learn to respect the opposing view. We all need to learn to disagree with respect. This is our national delima that when we disagree we lose temper and cant absorb why the other person does not think on the same lines i do. |
Hussain replied on Friday, June 15, 2007 12:24 PM PST
Dear 'The real ali'
It is my unbiased opinion that u got offended without any reason, Mr. Visitor has the right to differ with anyone on solid reasons. |
Aziz replied on Friday, June 15, 2007 03:18 PM PST
Dear Hussain Bhai,
Thank you very much for such a detailed analysis & timefor posting the valusable comments.
Dear Real Ali,
I have noticed that you are some what very uncomfortable with DHA, and usually do not like any one taking its side or speaking for it. It is just a brotherly request to let people say what they have to say and you also share your views with us all.
Thanks |
tzk replied on Saturday, June 16, 2007 07:30 AM PST
dear real ali
It is always hard to understand others point of view. It is a lot of times thought how come the other person does not understand something so simple. The actual reason is that two people are looking at the same thing from two different angels.
Please dont get offended when people say something about one society or the other and you can not absorb the reason behind their statements |
Hussain Kaisrani replied on Sunday, June 17, 2007 01:54 PM PST
Salaam and Thanks for comments of friends.
I am here again to provide latest updates regarding my post.
The main problem in Safari Villas was too much electricity shut down which created serious problems for three days. It is worth mentioning that Bahria Town management took the matter seriously and ordered a new power generator (worth Thirty million Rupees) which has been installed and started working from yesterday.
After solution of this big problem and due to wonderful weather, life is more enjoyable in Safari Villas nowadays.
Thanks. |
Usman, UK replied on Monday, June 18, 2007 03:17 PM PST
Dear Mr.Kaisrani,
thanks for sharing your views and experience. I just want to support what you said as I have the same experience as my family is living there. It is simply wonderful. Distance is not a big problem if you have your convayance. It is rather better to be in a quiet and clear atmosphere. If someone wants to construct a house, BT is the best place at present. If you want to invest for some quick return, then keep on playing around in different societies including DHA. No society at present matches with BT in terms of its standards of development and facilities. It is crystal clear. Bt is going to the winner finally due to its development standards, facilities,and low price. I was shocked to see a picture of house under construction in Phase-6, in an latest post. Just compare it with BT, you will get what I want to say. No further comments as it may hurt many on this forum. |
|