Shah® replied on Thursday, June 30, 2016 11:17 AM
Guys Despite being an investor myself, with a reasonably extensive portfolio of investments in multiple phases of DHA both in residential and commercial, and hence being a direct affectee of these newly imposed taxes, I still feel its in the best interest of the country to have the real estate income taxed. Although this tax is highly unlikely to give any benefit to common man or to the country itself, and will most likely end up in some off shore account in some far corner of the world somewhere, but the very fact that investments will likely be diverted towards a productive area of economy instead of this non-productive passive area of real estate is rather healthy for the country in the long run. My only complaint and resentment however, is the way this has been played by Govt. Too much too soon. This should have been done gradually over 2-3 years. With enough reaction time to both buyers and sellers to make informed decisions and then diluting the increased burden by doing it in incremental steps. The notice was so short that most people couldn't off load their investments in time before the closing of current fiscal year (non of the expats could come ti pak in such short notice to sell their plot) and from tomorrow onwards will come under the new tax net. Just to give you an example example, I sold and transferred a one kanal plot today in Phase 4 and paid 76,000 PKR as the total tax on the sale being a seller. On the sale of the same plot tomorrow, in less than 24 hours from now) on which I paid 76,000 tax today the tax imposed will be in the upwards of 20 lac Rs !!!! Thats too big a shock wave to be sent to any market (real estate in this case) unless you want it completely collapsed for some reason. Only an idiot would impose 10% tax (from 0 % CGT practically in effect) over night. And idiots unfortunately are a dime a dozen here ! ....of Idiots, by idiots,....for idiots..... :) |