Lahore Real Estate Forum

                                                          
 
Back to Forum |

Lahore Real Estate Forum: Property News & Community Talk : ,

(54894)
Monday, September 21, 2009 02:10 AM 

Without any intent to provoke controversy, attached is world map of crescent visibility on 19 Sep 2009.

The color coding is as following.

• Red: It is impossible to see the crescent from the areas located under the red color. Because either the Moon on this day sets before the Sunset and/or the topocentric conjunction occurs after the Sunset.
• White: The crescent can not be seen from uncolored areas, even though the Moon sets in these locations after the Sunset and the topocentric conjunction occurs before the Sunset, but the Moon is not sufficiently illuminated in order to be seen as crescent even by optical aid.
• Blue: The crescent is expected to be seen by optical aid only from the areas located under the blue color.
• Magenta: The crescent is expected to be seen by optical aid from the areas located under the magenta color. In these areas the crescent could be seen by naked eye if the atmospheric conditions are superb and the observer is experienced.
• Green: The crescent is expected to be easily visible by naked eye from the areas located under the green color.

(the map was generated using software "Accurate Times" available at http://www.icoproject.org/accu_setup.exe)

limo replied on Monday, September 21, 2009 04:25 PM 

Happy Eid Naveed.
Visibility of crescent on 20th Sep looks perfect and our region (Pakistan) is falling under green on that date.But in Saudia they claimed to have seen the moon on 19th Sep (this software shows this region under red on this date, meaning no chance of crescent being visible).Am i not drawing it well or sometimes such sofwares may be erratic.

Naveed Yaseen replied on Tuesday, September 22, 2009 03:44 AM 

Eid Mubarak!

For Sep 19 crescent visibility the map drawn by software should be very similar to the map attached to this post (i.e. Saudi Arabia should be mostly white instead of red shaded). Try following command sequence in the software...

'Crescent Visibility' > set Day/Month/Year > Preview > in section 'Day of Calculations' select 19 sep > 'Crescent Visiblity Map' > in section 'Visibility Day' select 19 sep > 'Draw'

Per generated map the most of Saudi Arabia is in white section or a part in blue. That means it was highly unlikely to view crescent by unaided eye in Saudi Arabia on Sep 19. I would like to know if anyone located in white or blue areas (which includes NWFP and Saudi Arabia) had himself/herself seen crescent on Sep 19.

I don't think software is erratic because we can use three different mathematical formulations and all result in more or less similar map.

Hassan replied on Wednesday, September 23, 2009 02:30 AM 

http://moonsighting.com/1430shw.html

Alireza Mehrani (MCW member) Esfahan Iran reported: Seen w/telescope
As it has been foreseen and expected before, the crescent of Shawal 1430 has been observed by 6 Iranian experienced observers on Saturday 19 Sept. by using telescope. I would like to emphasize that this observation was direct and it was not image-processing. Because of the rainy and cloudy weather in the northern part of Iran, other groups which were in this area were not able to observe the crescent.

guest************** replied on Wednesday, September 23, 2009 05:01 AM 

in Kuwait on 20th september the cresent was more clear, thick and remain visible for almost late night, it was clear that cresent was age of more than 48 hours, I think in Gulf the 19th sep EID decision was quite correct.

limo replied on Wednesday, September 23, 2009 12:25 PM 

I agree with quest, but the software is not supporting that!
>