“Response to brother Atif in discussion of post 12558”
Feelings of pain, frustration and anger in your post are very obvious. To a common reader your analysis may appear to be correct but problems we face as a nation are more complex. We can not just blame army, civil servants, any individual or group of people for all our problems, after all they come from our society and they are not foreign occupiers. Now, should we blame our own society, our values, ourselves, our parents, our grandparents who nurtured these values? The answer is no. Pakistani nation did not exist before 1947. Being muslims does not make us one nation. We may stress this point as often as we want but this is far from reality and should be considered as a political statement. Although people who called themselves muslims and who inhabit geographical area called Pakistan are more in numbers but they are divided in different sects and each sect considers other being non muslims and by the way there are people of other faiths who also inhabit that region and are part of Pakistani nation. One root cause of our problems lies right there. We still have been struggling to live in harmony with people of different sect or beliefs since we got the status of a nation. The other root cause lies in the fact that like a chick which just comes out of an egg, we had started walking behind the “murghee”. Again, we can not entirely blame army and civil bureaucracy for that. Geopolitical situation compelled us to do that otherwise we would have perished as a nation. With the passage of time “murghee” got old and was not able to provide us necessary security, so it gave that responsibility to a “murgha”. This “murgha” had a dubious character. Although from time to time it provided us with security but always wanted something in return and on many occasion roughed us up as well. We wanted it to be friend but it always treated us like a master. Although young, we are now quite grown up as a nation and our muscles have also become visible to others so it is time that we develop confidence and shun the policy of looking towards others for security. This way we will become a true independent nation, but achieving that status will require some efforts and here are some:-
-God does not send savior any more. We should stop looking for one and instead build and strengthen our institutions. Only strong and effective institutions can guarantee order in the society and protect the rights of a common citizen. A good ruler should always try to strengthen the institutions instead of making people dependent on him or her.
-Our teachers in colleges, universities and religious schools are the true leaders. We should ensure that these positions are filled by the most capable segment of the society.
-Our civil servants and army personnel should now realize that they are no longer on the payroll of Queen of England, their salaries are paid by the poor people of the nation and they are brought in the office to serve the people and not to rule the people. All our academies and educational institutions should prepare individuals for that.
There will be many more suggestions and by the way even if there is no winner, a nation is entitled to claim a victory in a war which it fights against an enemy which is one of the most privileged in the world and five times of its size.
:flg
Rustam Mirza replied on Friday, December 2, 2005 06:16 PM PST
Mr. wajid, Everyone knows that military generals are the richest people in Pakistan. How? dont know. And if you are giving an example of india, dont forget that they have been practicing democracy for the last 50 years and china is following socialism since its birth. So both democracy and socialism help poor of the country, democracy for their rights and socialism for their economy. Unfortunately in Pakistan your unelected and undisputed generals have robbed the people from their democratic right. According to internatinal standards, if you dont have a working constitution, you are not a nation by itself. Inconclusion pakistan needs a real working democracy, in which people of Pakistan should be given right to choose their leader and to replace him with better option when they need.
Regarding Dams, there are four provinces of Pakistan, they have to decide whether it is feasible for them to make a dam. Already we have lost one part of our country beacuse of the same autocratic attitude. Let this time be a healthy discussion. |